1.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:50:00
He's below average.


2.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:52:29
I'll still be negative lol. good shot stopper. but no where near what we need. Half our defensive wobbles comes through his lack of communication and inability to organise a defence.


3.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:52:46
Had a great game against Hoff and end of season but was woeful against Watford, he has had good spells before but he is still simply not a top top keeper. I don't like to get at players but he has played for us for long enough to see that won't change based on so many performances, he still looks a mess coming for crosses and coming out of goal. I really can't imagine him being in a league winning team, I would say at least half the team's in the prem have better keepers. I hate to say cos he seems to love the club and be a good guy but i really can't wait til we get a decent keeper, I hope ward is that man as karius, although young I personally think he's not shown signs that he is.


4.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:55:32
Are you having a laugh? Although he improved in the second half of last season. He looks like the nervous Nerys that he was in the first half of last season. He has conceded 4 in 2 games. He is getting some slack for saving a penalty in Hoffenhem.


5.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:57:25
below average keeper saved a pen and couple of other good saves to keep us in the champions league.


6.) 16 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 22:58:26
Natural are you serious what world are you living on pal he was absolutely toffee against Watford and mediocre against hoffenheim also I don't know what match Gerrard was watching last night when he said the save made the penalty look poor it was a mediocre penalty at best mignolet is not good enough to be first choice my opinion on performance it should go to ward.


7.) 17 Aug 2017
16 Aug 2017 23:51:10
I don't like being down on players, but the best Migs has shown us in four years is slightly less than half a season worth of not making mistakes. He still doesn't command his area or organise the defence, he still can't pass for toffee and his shot stopping isn't actually anything special. He did alright last night. But that's the best he ever is. Alright. Not good. Just okay. And I don't trust him to keep even that level up.

If the best we could say about Henderson or Can was that they hadn't made a mistake leading to a goal since February or so and had otherwise been completely average, people would be screaming for them to be replaced. Hell, some people are screaming for them to replaced anyway.

To a degree, I can understand Klopp not putting Karius in, because although I think he's a better goalkeeper in nearly every way than Migs, he seems to have serious issues keeping his concentration and none of us would exactly die of surprise if he let a back pass roll under his foot and into the net, but why not Ward?

More to the point, if the coaching staff believe that Karius and Ward aren't good enough to displace Mignolet (who is obviously not good enough), then why are all of them still here? Why haven't tried to get someone who is good enough? Apart from the left side of our defence, it's the area we most need to improve in, yet we're now going into a fifth season with a goalie who isn't good enough as first choice, who amazingly gets praised by some people when he saves shots that are at him.


8.) 17 Aug 2017
17 Aug 2017 00:00:33
I think he struggles with confidence sometimes. Let's hope he doesn't come on this site to hear what some of our so called fans say about him.


9.) 17 Aug 2017
17 Aug 2017 00:12:37
Who are these 10 better keepers? Lloris granted is the best in the league and De Gea is also better, couple of others may be significantly better but how many other keepers in EPL are sufficiently better to make the team championship material? And how many of those are available - the answer to first is not 10 and the answer to second is a big fat zero.

That isn't to big him up by the way but to state that this idea there are 10 better keepers at least in the EPL is exageration. There is a big gap in quality keepers these days and right now Mignolet is very much part of a decent but not special bunch. And don't seriously believe LFC is going to get a top level keeper any time soon. You could sign one of the "better" keepers and the difference will be barely noticeable. Very few in the world today are any good at coming for the ball or organising defences. The latter is hardly a surprise since so few teams actually rely on their keepers to do it these days. As I say moan all you like but there isn't a top level keeper moving to Merseyside in the near future so the club needs to make things work with what they have. It is one position that no amount of money is going to solve. So plenty of lipstick required for that particular pig I'm afraid.


10.) 17 Aug 2017
17 Aug 2017 00:23:25
Lloris
De gea
Cech
Ospina
Pickford
KARIUS
Schmeicheal
Begovic
Butland
Hart.


11.) 17 Aug 2017
17 Aug 2017 00:23:25
Lloris
De gea
Cech
Ospina
Pickford
KARIUS
Schmeicheal
Begovic
Butland
Hart.