09 May 2017 11:24:11
Ed01 was just wondering what you think of Brendan Rodgers? I think back when he was our manager you may have said he was an excellent coach just a very bad manager? I think we didn't do too bad under him we played some great football but also some very bad days that I would much rather forget (stoke) . He has gone to Celtic and won Manager of the year in his first year and won the league by a long shot. Do you think he has what it takes to make it at a big club again?

{Ed001's Note - well Celtic are a big club to be fair. In a competitive league though, no. He still is far too fond of talking about himself and making everything all about him. It will cause the same problems it caused when he managed us, with players getting annoyed with always being to blame for anything bad, while never getting any credit for doing well.

We have still to see if he has learnt in the transfer market as well. Will he swamp the Celtic squad with attacking midfielders and buy lots of players who are not quite good enough, or will he keep the additions down? Basically, what I am saying is that it is far too early to tell if he has learnt anything. Right now he is getting by on being an ex-Liverpool manager gracing the little SPFL, so to speak. With no competition to speak of, there was no chance of that bubble bursting immediately to see what he is actually about.}

1.) 09 May 2017
09 May 2017 12:59:47
We all knew he was Gona win the league with celtic. He's done that to get some trophies on his cv and then talk his way into a bigger job. Ed is spot on with his assessment. Think we could all win the league if we were in charge of celtic tho.

2.) 09 May 2017
09 May 2017 13:10:46
Thanks ed for the reply ed. I wasn't trying to call Celtic a small club or anything. I think he would make a good coach ed with an experienced director of football under him. I don't like him as a person if I'm being honest after letting Pascoe and Marsh basically take the blame for his poor management by giving them the sack.

{Ed001's Note - that was extremely distasteful, Pascoe was meant to be a good friend of his. Shows a lack of loyalty.}

3.) 09 May 2017
09 May 2017 14:32:20
BR is still who he is and that has not changed. Neil Lennon won a hatful of trophies at Celtic and actually had a good record in the CL with them. Where is he now? BR has not changed cos he prolly thinks he is better than he actually is cos he won trophies in a league my granny would win if she was manager.

He will milk the fact that he nearly won the PL with LFC all the way dry even tho, he is a woeful manager and even a more distrustful person with what he did to his assistants to save his skin. Pathetic lack of dignity, honor and loyalty from him.