Liverpool Banter Archive June 21 2016

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.

21 Jun 2016 20:40:21
Hi Reds and Eds,

I was just wondering about any players that I would like to see playing at liverpool, so i thought let's have a bit of fun while it's all quiet on the transfer front,

to all the red's what player in the euro's would you like to see playing for liverpool and in what position, it's just a bit of fun don't forget

I've alway's liked Luca Modric, he's hard working and can turn a game also i think he would fit into our team because he play's like an english player, i know i could have picked Ronaldo or other top names but i will stick with Modric,

What do the other red's and Ed's think,

Also you can only pick the one player, it will be interesting to see who some red fans choose.

Believable3 Unbelievable2

21 Jun 2016 20:57:49
Joe Allen. Oh wait 🤔

Bale for me all day long.


21 Jun 2016 21:01:26
I thought William carvalho looks a beast and personally would love to see him in the red of lfc.


21 Jun 2016 21:03:00
Pogba, Ronaldo, Neuer, Jordi Alba, Morata.


21 Jun 2016 21:13:08
Iniesta for me. imagine him picking out sturridge etc.


21 Jun 2016 21:18:12
Michael McGovern! 😊.


21 Jun 2016 21:40:02
I know he hasn't played much but Carrasco the Belgium is a real talent.


21 Jun 2016 21:42:44
We already have the welsh xavi/ pirlo il take the welsh bale.


21 Jun 2016 21:45:06
Would like to change my mind. perisic please. :-D.


21 Jun 2016 22:25:27
Candreva would be good for us on the right Imo.


21 Jun 2016 22:27:33
Bale. He would win us what, 20 points minimum per season.


21 Jun 2016 22:40:17
Neymar, Pogba, Aguero*.


21 Jun 2016 23:18:36
This evening's blunder notwithstanding, David DeGea.


21 Jun 2016 23:12:37
Perisic.


21 Jun 2016 23:43:12
Griezman.


22 Jun 2016 00:15:05
There is only one correct answer to that question and that is Will Grigg! :P.


22 Jun 2016 00:42:18
Silva and Villa when we had the two almost signed.


22 Jun 2016 00:13:32
and yeah morata.


21 Jun 2016 22:38:31
modric plays like an english player? i laughed so hard hahahaha. as a croatian there are currently 4 or 5 players aged 17 to 19 that have real potential of becoming players like modric and rakitic. real pool of talent. marko pjaca will be excellent player and his atitude is top class i would pick him. perisic is off to chelsea as one of his friends told me not 100% but almost can any of the eds confirm?


22 Jun 2016 08:34:54
Dimitri payet.


21 Jun 2016 19:25:13
Hi eds,

Do you think all this talk of Allen and how 'great' he's been at the Euros, could increase his value if he were to be sold in the summer?

Mind, I don't get the hype cause I think he's bang average, but the pundits are praising him non-stop. But would Liverpool want a higher asking price? (Obviously it depends if Wales continue to do well, but still, very curious) . Thanks.

Believable1 Unbelievable8

{Ed001's Note - I doubt it will make any difference. Sadly.}

21 Jun 2016 20:27:29
I think he's done a decent enough job when needed this season. And he wasn't getting regular time, and he's young. We could certainly have worse players.


21 Jun 2016 20:50:31
Joe Allen has been a hero for Wales during the euros regardless of what a lot of people think. Being a proud Welshman myself I wouldn't slate him even if he was playing crap #TogetherStronger #JoeAllenAppreciationDay.


22 Jun 2016 00:07:28
Wales is a workmanlike team with no stand out stars bar Bale so that fits him nicely. For a team like LFC that's trying to get over the hump, his qualities will simply not cut it here so for me, he goes.


22 Jun 2016 02:26:21
Allen has improved a lot since jurgen took over. From what I've seen we aren't exactly bringing anyone better than him. Yes zielinski is more forward thinking but in terms of quality I wouldn't say he's better than him especially recently. I mean, I'm assuming everyone watched him today and came to the same conclusion. But it's not 'just one game' I've watched him 3 full matches he played for empoli and he was literally no better, only difference is empoli didn't have a better player to bring on. We are just replacing average with average, and apparently we are wanting to get top 4.


22 Jun 2016 02:28:12
Agreed redohio.


22 Jun 2016 05:18:50
i'd keep allen over the likes of midfielders we are looking at. he is decent, does his job, runs around aimlessly, has good short range passing, can tackle. Always wanted to see a Hendo allen Can midfield.
for me grujic lucas and brannagan add up depth to the squad. i see no point in adding players that we are being linked on cost of allen.

All we need is selling out players trimming the squad and adding a winger.


21 Jun 2016 18:53:14
Right ed001. I no you don't like these questions mate but in your opinion are we more likely to sign Gotze or Mane? Also who would you prefer please?

Believable3 Unbelievable4

{Ed001's Note - I really could not answer who is more likely, but I would not want either.}

21 Jun 2016 19:45:47
Ok mate fair enough. I no what ya saying. Seems we are after them though. Both maybe?


21 Jun 2016 19:56:38
I don't want Mane I know that much.


21 Jun 2016 20:30:42
Gotze over mane but don't want him either.


21 Jun 2016 20:24:29
Ed001 - who would you recommend LFC go for in lieu of Gotze and Mane?


{Ed001's Note - I haven't seen anyone I would recommend to be honest. For me, I would like to see what the likes of Ojo can do first.}

21 Jun 2016 20:26:46
I thought you said mane has all the skill sets we are needing ed001?

What players are we targeting that you are hoping for? Or who would you pursue that is reasonable. (You can ignore left and right backs as I don't think there are any you like :) )


{Ed001's Note - Mane has all the ability but not the attitude to make the most of it. He skips training and team meetings, throws tantrums and generally needs to grow up. Avoid at all costs as those kind of players are a poison in the dressing room.

Right now, I am happy with what we have. It is more important that we keep our better players fit, in my opinion, than buy.}

21 Jun 2016 22:43:17
Agreed #1. I am really excited about Ojo the lad can be a real star in my opinion, if he stops with us we're laughing in the near future. there's been talk of him been moved on, tell me it's daft rumours?


22 Jun 2016 00:09:13
Don't want Gotze, Mane or Zeilinski. Either we get who will improve us or we stick with what we have.


21 Jun 2016 18:01:58
After watching a lot of the football in the euro's i can't pick out a player who i would want for us to buy, i know there's Payet but we have see him all season on M. O. T. D plus i don't think he would come to us also there might be the big boys going in for him, there's been no stand out performers in fact i think a lot of the big players have not performed well at all maybe they will play better in the knockout games, that's what i think any way i'm waiting for it to take off really, or maybe one of the under dogs will win the euro's just like the way leicester won the prem, it could be the year of the under dogs.

Believable5 Unbelievable1

21 Jun 2016 18:55:37
Probably because euro's has been awful so far.


21 Jun 2016 19:00:22
I'm impressed with hector the more I watch him the more it's a must that we sign him. I'd rather we spent £30m on him than mane. Also Granit Xakha looks the real deal and will slot straight into that Arsenal midfield gutted to be honest going to make top 4 that little bit harder.


21 Jun 2016 20:49:01
£30 million for Jonas Hector? I hope that is a flippant comment Dave!

Xhaka looks good, but Krychowiak looks an outstanding player and the young Polish winger Kapustka has got my eye.


22 Jun 2016 00:10:49
Kaputska, Andre Gomez and William Carvalho have impressed me.


21 Jun 2016 22:02:23
AG

I was the first one to bring Krychowaik name to the site at least an year ago. He has been outstanding from couple of years.


21 Jun 2016 17:47:42
I think Clyne had a good game last night, i'm not one for stats because they don't tell the whole truth but Clynes stats are better than Walkers for Englands right back which should make a lot of liverpool fans happy because Kyle Walker is a good right back but if Clyne has better stats then it makes him better than Walker, i think once we have a settled back 4 next season our results will get better, and i think the new GK will do well if and only if we get a new GK coach, plus the competion for the GK spot will make the GK's better for us so let's hope we get the players who Klopp wants and we have a good pre-season then the season will be a very good one for us, i'm really looking forward to next season because i believe in Klopp and i hope he has many years with us, i think it took Klopp 3 season to get Dortmund to where they are now and challenging for the german title so let's hope he does the same with us, it will take him that long to get all the players he needs to make it his team of players.

Believable3 Unbelievable10

21 Jun 2016 17:55:35
Personally not a fan of stats because it depends on who the opposition is.

Makes me laugh when they compare players stats from different leagues. How can you compare a players stats from the prem with a players stats from the Dutch league.


22 Jun 2016 00:11:46
Stats are pointless, end of. Your eyes are the best way to judge a player. Use them.


21 Jun 2016 16:13:00
Hi eds. is there any truth in the rumours sorounding hamsik from napoli? Looked a very handy player 2 seasons ago but not seen much of him since. Not shown much of himself in euros from what I've seen. What's your take on him?

Believable1 Unbelievable3

{Ed091's Note - Hamsik will not be moving to Liverpool.

21 Jun 2016 17:08:20
Cheers eds. Another piece of lazy journalism.


21 Jun 2016 20:32:07
Learn to ignore these daft rumours mate, will be plenty more, tomorrow I heard we're signing Kroos.


21 Jun 2016 13:36:59
It's Joe Allen Appreciation day so let's all day something nice about the legend. Lathe guy has a mighty fine beard.

Believable10 Unbelievable1

21 Jun 2016 14:02:29
His chickens look really healthy!


21 Jun 2016 15:06:49
He has two feet.


21 Jun 2016 15:18:28
Welshy wizard.


21 Jun 2016 15:28:38
He makes Henderson look world class.


21 Jun 2016 15:42:06
Good professional 😎.


21 Jun 2016 15:51:43
His 8 yard pass is perfection.


21 Jun 2016 16:08:43
Great character the wee little man.


21 Jun 2016 16:08:43
Great character the wee little man.


21 Jun 2016 16:26:27
The Welsh Pirlo.


21 Jun 2016 16:35:15
Pirlo is the itallian Allen.


21 Jun 2016 16:46:16
He has never failed this city (yet)


21 Jun 2016 16:51:45
Chris Coleman (me and the lads especially my ape brother Gareth and also captain Ash Williams like to call him Christina Colewoman due to his particularly funny name lol and also the fact that his pa was a coal worker who died in a mining accident) said I could have the next few days off because of this National Holiday so I'll be down the old Ship and Mitre drinking my sorrows away (why does she have to be with him for goodness sake) . Chris saw some of the posts on here and chuckled but then ruffled my lovely beard I asked him to stop but he continued to do it in the manner of a dirty man oh well there's always Euro 2020.


21 Jun 2016 13:46:30
What do people think of creswell off west ham I'd love to have him at the club.

Believable1 Unbelievable6

21 Jun 2016 14:01:37
Manages to play consistently well without ever putting in a standout performance.

I suppose for a defender it is good when you go unnoticed. Not sure he is the quality we need, or if he has the potential to get to that level though.

Definitely not a bad player either way.


21 Jun 2016 15:22:17
Good player but were not in need in my opinion.


21 Jun 2016 10:48:34
Hello House,
Looking at the posts here, it would appear we are not in for any central attacker, if so could the Eds give their opinion of if they agree we are well stocked in that department (Stu, Origi and Ings) or like me believe we need an injury-free 20/ 25 goal a season striker?

Believable1 Unbelievable9

{Ed002's Note - The club is overrun with forwards.}

21 Jun 2016 12:30:03
Ings, benteke, balo, origi, Sturridge and Firmino as an option. Think we're okay unless we lose 2-3 of those.


21 Jun 2016 12:38:24
Over run with forwards, who won't get 20/ 25 goals a season like the op said!


{Ed002's Note - We get it, you are a Liverpool supporter who wants a new set of players every year. Not only is it really embarrassing to keep reading these posts, I thought the Almighty Klipperty would work his magic with them all. If Firmino were to go then perhaps another forward who scores mpre goals might come in - or just perhaps yet another attcking midfield player.}

21 Jun 2016 13:43:53
Firmino in his first league campaign got 10 goals despite missing a month out injured and only playing as a striker for the final third of the season. Plus Klopp rested him for the last 4 league games. Suarez in his first season got 11 league goals playing more games in a more consistent advanced position.

I'm not saying Firmino will bang in 23 next season just because Suarez did, but he will certainly improve on his tally of 10, Sturridge is finally fit and firing so he could easily bag 20, and if we sign Gotze or Mane, for all the negativity they will still hit double figures.

No need for this negativity lads.

I think people will also be surprised by Zielinski if and when he signs. He could easily hit 5+ goals from midfield. He got 5 last season playing in a very average team in a very compact league. With better players around him in a much more open league, he could get a lot of goals for a midfielder.

If Henderson stays fit he is a proven 5+ goal a season midfielder.

Lallana and Milner can and will chip in with a few each.

Not to mention Ings and Origi who will grab goals even if it's just off the bench or rotating with Sturridge.

We have not had a problem with scoring under Klopp. I think after Christmas we were one of the top scoring teams in the league. Our problem was controlling midfield (because Hendo was injured so we had the headless chicken duo of Allen and Milner) and keeping the ball out of our own net (courtesy of Moreno, Skrtel and Mignolet mainly) .

Hendo being fit and Karius, Matip and probably Chilwell signing already makes next season one to look forward too. Add Grujic, Zielinski and possibly Gotze to that and we can beat anyone on our day with Klopp in charge.

Let's not forget that last seasons team beat Dortmund over 2 legs without our captain. We are not a bad team.


21 Jun 2016 15:14:01
Benteke and balo won't be at the club next season and Firmino is a attacking midfielder he was when we signed him and is now.


21 Jun 2016 15:31:25
yes dezyboy bt that still leaves us with ings studge and origi fighting for 1 spot.


21 Jun 2016 15:50:59
Dezyboy, he is still a young player. We signed him as an attacking midfield player, but all of his best performances came as a striker. He has been almost exclusively used as a striker by the Brazilian national team as well.

Players change position as they develop. Lucas joined us as the best young attacking midfielder in Brazil and ended up being a great holding midfielder. Ireland had a striker on as a sub the other day who came through the system as a goal keeper. You see what I mean?

Firmino is very clearly seen as a forward by Klopp. Be that anywhere in a front 3, as a second striker, or leading the line by himself. He hasn't played attacking midfield since Rodgers was given the boot.


21 Jun 2016 15:23:55
Mk and ed1 spot on.


21 Jun 2016 15:24:18
Ed2 I mean.


21 Jun 2016 13:10:06
Personally I don't think we need to bring in another striker. Assuming we can find buyers for benteke, ballotelli and yesil it will leave us with sturridge, origi and ings and will also have firminio to cover as I don't see him as an out and out striker. The only way I think we'll buy in the striker is if one of sturridge or firminio is sold. But I'm happy to stick with what we have and hopefully they can all stay fit.


21 Jun 2016 18:24:10
Kaizer, you don't think 3 players fighting for one spot is too many do you? Sturridge has a history of injuries, I hope he's over them now but you never know, Origi is a young lad who looks like he could be special, but we'll have to wait and see and Ings at the moment, is in the same situation as Sturridge (injury issues) .

I think promoting a young lad, rather than buying another striker would be the best option. Especially as Klopp likes to play Firmino as a striker.

For me though, Ings has to be the main man up top. Just my opinion though, I think he suits the system best.


21 Jun 2016 21:02:54
I've got a strange feeling we're going to sell Couts, move studge to the right to cut in on that left peg, and buy a new striker.
Really don't want too, but I'm thinking we will.


21 Jun 2016 11:03:13
Everyone having a good debate on Lallana (who earned a right for another season under klopp)

What about firmino if he starts well he is top class scores goals has assists two bit he had some woeful games two more bad then good I'm hoping it was first season learning myself what's everyone else's opinion.

Believable3 Unbelievable5

21 Jun 2016 11:46:35
I would say Lallana could easily be culled myself.
Looks good but ineffective for me.


21 Jun 2016 11:47:49
Expect him to get better and better.


21 Jun 2016 12:01:38
Firmino is your average under rated player whose good work goes un noticed and whose bad games are always remembered. Every team needs a player like Firmino, who quietly does his work with minimum fuss and notice and yet delivers when it most matters.
Statwise -10 goals and 8 assists in first season in EPL is definitely something to look at. I am not sure if anyone else has quite done that in their first season. I think he is one of our players who i wish starts and keeps on doing what he does may be with a tee-wee bit more impetus. 3 up front with studger origi/ ings firmino sounds tasty to me.


21 Jun 2016 12:22:35
what you also have to remember about firmino is that last year under Rodgers he was not played in a area that suited him, then when klopp arrived his goals and assists came from being played in areas that suited him, I agree he can be frustrating but when he is on form he is a joy to watch, now he has has a season in the premier league and knows what its all about I expect him to get better, he is more than capable in reaching double figures in goals and assists.


21 Jun 2016 13:40:26
I like Lallana for work rate and passion, also he clearly tried to output Klopps demands for pressing. He also has obvious natural ability but ineffective.

That's where it's ends. He just isn't good enough and a waste of such a high fee. Rarely scores, rarely assists but frequently stunts attacks with extra touches or swivels and passing back rather then forward.

Also add he doesn't make intelligent runs and is not a winger.


21 Jun 2016 14:25:19
Llalana has been, debatably Englands best player at the euros, certainly in the top 3 . He glides past players his touch and turns are as good as anyone not to mention his work rate, granted he sometimes takes too many toches and he should score more often, But all i'm all he is a good player .


21 Jun 2016 16:05:49
Firmino's work off the ball is actually as important as the goals and assists he brings in. He's always running into open spaces and always stretching the defences. You find him literally all over the final third of the pitch. Something that you don't always notice unless you're in the stadium and track him visually. And he's always looking for someone to pass off to. Makes the players around him look much better than they are.


21 Jun 2016 18:28:21
I think if you're playing a pressing system, Lallana, Ings and probably Coutinho are the best 3 (in our current squad) to have on the field. Especially if we're playing with 2 wide forwards.

Ings reminds me of a hyperactive dog, he never stops chasing, never stops running and he scores goals. He's going to be a very welcome site when he comes back into the first team.

Anyway, if Ings has issue's with injuries, he could always go into boxing, he seems to be fairly skilled in that sport from what I've read.


21 Jun 2016 08:53:57
Not a rumour, just wondering what the ed's opinions on Henderson are, lots of sheep on social media who slate him when he has played well, personally i think he helps to make players around him better with the shift he puts in and is an under rated creative force, never be world class, but a good player to have.

What's your analysis please ed's?

Thanks.

Believable3 Unbelievable4

{Ed001's Note - personally I really like him. He works hard, has a great range of passing, good defensive positioning, knows when to press and when to drop off and cover passing lanes, gets forward well and does most of the things that go unseen.

He needs to add more goals to his game. That is his major weakness. Also his tackling could do with work, but that is such a minor part of the game these days, that it is not worth worrying about, sadly. Oh and he is strong in the air, would like to see him getting on the end of some crosses, both in open play and from set pieces.

Hendo fully deserves a place in the side, despite the idiotic comments about his running style etc. It reminds me of something that stats analysts talk about, which is why they like to look at raw data. People make observations based on appearance, Hendo runs funny, so he is not rated. He does not look like he should be a footballer so people make assumptions.}

21 Jun 2016 09:27:55
Agreed Eds01. Without him i think we struggle and though i rate Lucas and Can also i think Henderson is much needed with at least one of the other two playing alongside him

And no i am not suggesting he has the same role as the other two, but compliments them and the team.


21 Jun 2016 09:47:58
Eds I completely agree and alongside Can is definitely the base for our midfield. I would just like to see someone in the mould of Dier or Xhaka, someone who can pick a pass when we're on top but who can sit in front of the back four or cover the full backs when they bomb forward. I think that is the missing ingredient to our midfield.


{Ed001's Note - the players should be able to figure that out between them, rather than wasting a midfielder by playing him as an auxiliary defender.}

21 Jun 2016 10:59:53
Ed001 that reminds me of how people see Sakho, he looks unconventional on the ball so people just assume he is a poor passer when quite the opposite is true. Anyway, I'm a massive fan of Henderson myself and I have my fingers crossed he stays fit next season.


{Ed001's Note - it is something the guy who started the stats revolution in baseball said. One of the reasons you can get better value via the stats was because people make judgements based on appearance. Sometimes someone can look wrong but be extremely effective, they will still be seen as rubbish by the vast majority because of that appearance.}

21 Jun 2016 11:01:38
Dier is brilliant to be fair.

I still don't get all the hype around Xhaka though. Awful discipline, concedes possession constantly, doesn't have that broad a range of passing. I think West Ham got the best Monchengladbach midfielder in Nordtveit. Dahoud has the most potential of the 3 for sure though. Xhaka just looked the best on highlight reels because of his all action style and the fact he shouts a lot. Probably a good leader to be captain at 23, but not a good player by any stretch. Coquelin is better by far. Wenger is losing it if you ask me.


21 Jun 2016 11:22:22
Yeah hendo should be scoring much more goals for me, he gets in the right positions but his finishing is dreadful.
Seems to bottle it or get over excited, I dunno. Maybe he just doesn't have the nerve to do it, like when someone goes up to take an important penalty in a shoot out and fires it into row Z, that's how I see hendo whenever he gets in a scoring position.
That post sounds really harsh looking back on it, as I think he's a really important player for us and one who's been badly missed. His main job isn't to score goals at the end of the day but it is frustrating.
Eds, are his injury problems past him now? Are we going to see the best of him this season?


{Ed001's Note - should be.}

21 Jun 2016 11:45:09
I'm a big fan of Hendo but his inability to cross a ball above the first defender last night was Milneresque.


21 Jun 2016 12:05:45
Hendo is club captain, and no one else really could be. he is a tidy player and probably that now he is fully fit we will see the best of him. We defo need him controlling games in the midfield. He for me is the best english midfielder currently.


21 Jun 2016 12:15:30
Eds but they don't figure it out though which is why our midfield is so easily overrun when we're defending. So if we don't need an auxiliary defender as you put it then that means one of Can or Hendo isn't good enough or they just don't fit together. MKSCOUSER Xhaka plays very similar to Dier, Dier plays us a bit more measured but Xhaka is a bit stronger hence the disciplinary record but has been the engine and beating heart of Switzerland, Monchengladbach and I think it was Basle. Very undervalued and happy for others like Shaqiri to grab the headlines. Very similar to William Carvalho of Portugal.


{Ed001's Note - we have never been overrun when Hendo is in there, it was while he was out we had problems.}

21 Jun 2016 12:24:57
just to add to hendo convo he's one of the most professional players around apparently, every manager he's had says this, stevie g too i recall, my point being he gives 100% on or off the pitch which i no should be given but as we all no isn't, for me he's a top player n i'm glad we got him.


21 Jun 2016 12:45:07
What would you say to joey Barton ed001, who last night tweeted that Hendo has no nerve endings in his feet and just kicks the ball hard everytime? Also he wrote can someone tell sturridge he's not on trial and is allowed to pass to a team mate!


{Ed001's Note - I would not waste my time talking to that bigoted moron who should have been locked up alongside his brother many years ago. It is only because the scummy little turd is a footballer that he is not in jail where he belongs. What he knows about football could be written on the back of a postage stamp with a very thick marker pen.}

21 Jun 2016 13:01:06
Ha ha ha ha that's just brilliant edd001 made my day that!


{Ed001's Note - he is a horrible little turd. The BBC should be ashamed of themselves letting him have a platform to spout his moronic crap on. His sole contribution to society is regurgitated quotes, as he does not have the intelligence to think of his own sayings, and violent acts perpetrated on those unable to defend themselves. Usually kids.}

21 Jun 2016 13:37:36
You say Barton is a footballer, Ed. I'd like to dispute that point.


21 Jun 2016 13:24:10
Unfortunate enough to have met joey a couple of times.
I think ed001s assessment on him is very inacurate, it's far far too kind on him.


{Ed001's Note - the sad thing is that he is probably the nicest member of his family!}

21 Jun 2016 16:03:32
Disagree tackling is a big part of the game especially for midfielders

Henderson lack quality but has such a good hard working engine and is a great team player he can do a job for any team.


21 Jun 2016 19:26:41
I personally love Hendo, He was a great and perfect successor to StevieG, for me he epitomises what it means to be a good Liverpol player. Had a very rocky start to his career at Anfield, and personally did not rate him too much, though I could see his potential. He grew into in my opinion one of our most important players. Has been said here before, that was because of his sending off towards the end of the 2013/ 14 that cost us the title, and I remember when it happened i had fears would cause us to lose us the title as he was soo important for our midfield. He may not get the goals or many assists as other midfielders, but his contribution is massive even if goes unnoticed by some, and his absensce is sorely felt when he is missing. I truely hope he can get fit and remain fit because he can become a legend for Liverpool and for England.


21 Jun 2016 20:24:51
I seem to spend my entire life arguing with people about Henderson. He is actually very technically gifted. He is more skillful than people give him credit for but he keeps it simple and doesn't needlessly use it. A bit like lallana does.

I agree with a poster that it his composure that he struggles with most he has all the attributes to get more goals than he does I just think that he puts a lot of pressure on himself. His finishing is best when he hasn't got time to think about it.

His crossing from open play is good he has vision, excellent range of passing.

All people seem to notice is his work rate but not the importance and the intelligence of it. Henderson is one of our few midfield players who will bust a gut to make an excellent run beyond a striker and then run back and know where he should be defensively.

As well as all this he is an excellent professional and despite the criticism I think he is an excellent captain.


21 Jun 2016 08:44:32
Can't believe I'm about to say it after all the times I'm expressed my bad opinions on Hendo but yesterday has changed my mind. He was excellent, fair play to the lad, shut up doubters (me) . Hope he can continue with such performances.

Believable10 Unbelievable6

21 Jun 2016 18:34:52
Is this the first time you've actually watched Henderson? He's been brilliant in most games for us.


21 Jun 2016 18:46:39
Good to see! People still seem to think he was poor yesterday for some reason. Everything good about England's play went through him. He created the best chances, found Clyne in good places time after time, and marked Hamsik out of the game. Just because he misplaced a few crosses his whole performance is criticized. At least he's actually getting into areas to create chances. If Rooney had played that pass to Vardy it would be talked about for weeks.


21 Jun 2016 20:15:28
Agreed you.

So true it's a different story should it of been Rooney making a decent pass, who quite frankly is terrible. Your right, Hendo really made the difference and totally changed my opinion.

hsf no mate it's not the first time I have watched him, watched him every single time he played since he joined and had few good games, didn't rate him at all until now. he's surprised me and I'm glad about that, always hoped he would do better and he is proving he can do better. with him in midfield next season is going to be definitely interesting, seeing what he can add is exciting to say the least.

I'm happy to be proven wrong.


21 Jun 2016 08:39:27
Very short one sentence article in the Mail saying that Sakho will find out in the next 2 weeks from UEFA if he's to be banned for failing the drugs test.

Thought I'd share.

Believable2 Unbelievable2

21 Jun 2016 08:43:50
2nd July I think it is.


21 Jun 2016 08:48:42
I thought he wasn't getting banned? Due to the substance not been on their list? Not kept up to date with it all but hopefully they leave him be.


21 Jun 2016 09:42:01
It was on the list Jürgen, but Sakho's defence is that it shouldn't be on the list and apparently their is some mileage in that argument.


21 Jun 2016 10:06:42
Oh I see, thanks Ron.


21 Jun 2016 11:30:33
Not sure I agree with sakhos argument though. If it's on the list, why was he taking it?
He should be checking everything. Especially a fat burner.


{Ed001's Note - something to do with there being confusion over the lists. I believe the argument is that it was not on the WADA list which FIFA and UEFA are supposed to follow but was still on the UEFA list. That is if I have understood it correctly. Difficult to follow and personally I agree with you, just don't take anything and you don't have to worry.}

21 Jun 2016 11:56:13
Ahh ok ed thanks that clears it up a bit.
Thought his argument was what he was taking shouldn't be on the list because it's not that bad (in his opinion) didn't know there was a discrepancy over the lists.
I do think if players are taking anything it should be run past the club doctor first.


21 Jun 2016 12:27:46
didn't kolo have an issue similar in the past ed's?


{Ed001's Note - if by similar issue you mean he was banned for being found guilty, then yes he did. There was no argument that the substance should not have been on the banned list though, he was simply at fault.}

21 Jun 2016 08:09:57
Anyone know if Mainz or Dortmund made a lot of signings during JKs first seasons with these teams. I doubt Mainz did . Basically my point is I'm most excited to see how JK gets the team to play not who plays in it. I think this should excite us more than maybe landing a fella with a german last name. If JK was able to get results without major signings before then why would we be any different. Leicester just won the league folks.

Believable5 Unbelievable4

21 Jun 2016 08:56:30
They didn't make a lot of signings. But Dortmund trimmed the first team squad by 17 players in Klopps first summer.

I think we will get Chilwell and Zielinski over the line. Then I only expect one more player. Possibly Gotze, Mane etc. Basically a goal scoring attacker to replace Coutinho who like it or not, wants CL football.

I can still see a lot more players leaving though.

Just from the senior squad/ loanees we'll probably lose Bogdan, Vigouroux, Enrique, Toure, Skrtel, Ilori, Wisdom, Allen, Rossiter, Teixeira, Canos, Ibe, Alberto, Markovic, Coutinho, Sinclair, Balotelli, Benteke and Yesil. That's already 19 players.

I know people aren't keen on Lallana, Moreno, Milner, Lucas and Mignolet but they won't be going anywhere if you ask me. Klopp rates Milner, Lallana and Lucas. As for Moreno and Mignolet, who would buy them after the season they've just had?

I do expect a much smaller and fine tuned squad next season though to allow the likes of Brannagan and Ojo chances to impress. Klopp is a big believer in giving youth a chance. You just can't do that with a 50 player squad.


21 Jun 2016 09:29:26
Well put MK.


21 Jun 2016 11:04:05
I think Coutinho stays this year. Gotze/ Mane will be an addition IMO.

I think Ibe will go.


21 Jun 2016 12:58:08
That is a lot of players and most of them simply dead wood and/ or not good enough. Huge saving in wages. And now that we don't have Europe this year we can trim the squad right down with pure quality over quantity. We can afford to play (almost) the same team week in week out - injuries permitting. Would like to see this done mainly with the back 4.


21 Jun 2016 17:07:38
Replacing Coutinho with Mane would be a mistake.

He would cost a fortune and it would take a large portion of the Coutinho money to bring him in (transfer fee, signing fee, agent, etc) .

A backwards step certainly in terms of quality, player attitude and effectiveness.


21 Jun 2016 07:58:34
Has anyone noticed that Sturridge has learned how to pass the ball, even when in sight of goal?
He's played a number of cracking through balls for England in the last couple of games. If he could be less greedy, I wouldn't be so 50/ 50 about whether to cash in or keep.

Believable0 Unbelievable10

21 Jun 2016 08:50:18
What? 50/ 50 about cashing in on him? Come off it, he's incredible and he's a Liverpool player. Leave it out.


21 Jun 2016 11:51:25
Maybe change his contract to a more appearance based wage next time his contract is up but never sell the lad. We have enough cover now to allow for his injuries anyway. When he is fit he is one our best players.


21 Jun 2016 07:49:02
After watching the England game last night it seemed to me that if Coutinho does leave, the formation England are currently using would suit Liverpool quite well. Sturridge, Origi and Firmino as a 'fluid' front 3, alternating positions, with hendo, can and either grujic (if he hits the ground running) or Lucas sitting behind to protect. Would allow both hendo and can to bomb on like they enjoy doing without needing to completely vacate the defensive midfield position. Obviously if coutinho stays this wouldn't work unless we dropped origi and went with a more rigid system up top as I have never been a fan of coutinho in CM whenever he's been played there.

Believable7 Unbelievable2

21 Jun 2016 08:12:05
Who would you have as a Lucas replacement, can't see him lasting a full season of full tilt sweeperish roles.


21 Jun 2016 08:54:39
Stewart.


21 Jun 2016 09:49:04
The team will change. Definitely Expecting more 1st team players especially like you say, if our best player does leave.


21 Jun 2016 05:34:03
Hi Eds',

This is continuation of my earlier post reg Lallana.

How can a player at another club look so good and when they play for us literally turn into nightmare?

ex: Lallana,

1. Is it to do with one season form and then they are back to their levels?

2. Is it to do with the tactics of the coach/ manager which makes them look awful?

3. Is it that they peak early and peter out? (similar to point 1)

We can add so many names in this category but we all will have an exception to the names.

Hence want to take Lallana's name as the only example and wish to discuss this trend.

Cheers,
SamiKewell.

Believable0 Unbelievable4

{Ed001's Note - tactics in the main. Different players require different ways of playing to get the most out of them. Look at Aaron Ramsey, there are times he looks a worldbeater, then he has to play a different role and looks awful. If you are not playing to the player's strengths, then they will not look good. That is why stats are so useless on their own, as they do not take into account the context of the play. How the player is being used etc.}

21 Jun 2016 05:45:44
Thanks for the quick response - Ed01.

So which is more important in football?

Ability of the player to adjust to different tactics / formations?
or
Individual skill that they bring to the pitch? (they should be really good in one or two things exceptionally)

or

Ability of the manager/ coach to put to use the available players and bring out the best in them as a team?

or

Push their tactics and ensure that players adapt to his line of thinking?

Sorry for so many question at once.

Cheers,
SamiKewell.


{Ed001's Note - the manager/coach is the most important thing. That is why the best managers end up at the most successful clubs. Even the best and most skilful players need a manager to set up his team to suit them. Messi went through a bad patch when Barca were not set up ideally for him. Now they are again working to his strengths, he was once again world class.

That is why Klopp is the most important signing we have made in recent years. It is also why Gerrard, for all his ability, failed to win the trophies he should have. He was just one player, but a manager works with all 11 on the pitch at once. Good players can work together on their own and produce great things sometimes, a manager ensures that the great things happen consistently.

In any walk of life, the leader is the most important thing. That is the person setting the tone of everything. The best managers are benign dictators. They make the decisions, but they also listen to input from others and work with their players to get the most out of them. Even ones likes Ferguson and Clough, that are presented by the media as ruling everything with an iron fist, listened to their players. They sometimes chose to ignore what was said, mostly in fact, but they did listen and would look to fit the way they worked to the players at their disposal.}

21 Jun 2016 06:22:38
Thanks once again for the detailed response.

Hope Klopp brings the best out of the individual players and uses them to his tactical point of view and this ends up in a good marriage. (at least 1 cup in 4 years)

Currently happy with Klopp but hoped he would have the pull to bring in some exciting players but somehow our position is undermining this and players are opting for better options.

Cheers,
SamiKewell.


{Ed001's Note - what Klopp and his staff opt for is players they feel will work best in the system they want to use. That should excite you more than a big name. Shanks and Paisley never targeted big names, they targeted the players that fitted the system.}

21 Jun 2016 08:46:28
Great post by the way! Good read :)


21 Jun 2016 08:53:44
Totally agree with what Ed has said, I couldn't care les if everyone we signed I'd never heard of in my in life. As long as they work as a team and a squad and are players that want to be at the club and want to succeed as a team. That's the most important thing and that's what makes a successful team.


21 Jun 2016 10:19:45
I am in total agreement, but i would like to include the role of a competent Captain who can correctly interpret the Coaches instructions on the pitch. He also is saddled with the role of having his hands on the pulse of the tide of play - knowing when to 'ginger; the boys, or when to make them sitback.


21 Jun 2016 12:37:16
we signed lallana off the back of him playing under poch, rodgers then used him incorrectly but now wi klopp whos similar to poch lallana thrived, i no he needs to score/ assist more but for me he'll improve again this season, also lallana is often the guy who sets up the assist which is as vital, i'm a liverpool supporter n will continue to do so YNWA.


21 Jun 2016 05:51:15
Lallana was awful yesterday. Doesn't score goals for both Liverpool and England. Allen looked a completely different player.


21 Jun 2016 13:03:49
Great post Ed's, we used to have "the Liverpool way" of playing. The sooner we get our identity back the better.


20 Jun 2016 21:30:00
Eds or fellow reds, can someone please tell me where the hell THIS Joe Allen has been when Liverpool have been playing?

Watching this as a Welshman I won't complain but it is too confusing.

Ed1, Amy ideas?

Believable1 Unbelievable2

{Ed001's Note - I have no idea what you are talking about, international football is no place to judge a player's ability. It is much slower paced and easier for players to shine, as they have so much more time. I am not watching the Euros.}

21 Jun 2016 05:40:59
Sorry RedNick.

Like Joe Allen as a good professional but his skills are pretty limited and international matches aren't the right platform for judging players.

You might get lucky once in a while but most of the times we end up badly like those guys we bought after Euro's some time back.

El Hadji Diouf and another guy with him. (is it salif diao? ) Total flops both.

Luckily Joe Allen is not in the same bracket but nothing great either. We have seem him recently hustling players like hound in the last few LFC matches and the opposition players still play like he even isn't there.

Did not see him play for Swansea and in the wales games against Eng, nothing much to write home. In fact they played too defensively. So can't comment on that performance.

Cheers,
Sami Kewell.


21 Jun 2016 06:48:51
It shows the danger of judging players based on YouTube or how they play in a different team IMO.


{Ed001's Note - that is why scouting is a specialised art all of its own. Why someone like Steve Walsh is so crucial to Leicester, over and above the stats analysts etc.}

21 Jun 2016 06:52:52
If you set international football as the main medium of measurement for a player's quality, Klose would be one of the greatest strikers in living memory. But like ed said, international football is slow-paced. Germany were lacking a superstar striker for a number of years and Klose had the fortune of playing with a great team to support his goalscoring.


21 Jun 2016 12:41:57
DAMN this must be why we missed out on david healy all those years back!


20 Jun 2016 23:56:17
Hi Eds,
Sorry to be a pain with questions.
Any news on Sakho (ban) or Markovic (future)?
I really think Markovic has more to offer than Mané or Zielinski.
Much Obliged

Ron.

Believable4 Unbelievable1

{Ed091's Note - Markovic will return and speak to klopp, Right now im not too sure what the hold up is with sakho, but seeing him in liverpool media things, suggests theyre relaxed.

21 Jun 2016 02:16:09
Ron, Sakho will learn his fate for failing a drugs test from UEFA in the next 2 weeks.


21 Jun 2016 06:49:50
Thanks all.


21 Jun 2016 07:38:59
I am with you on that Ron, seeing how Klopp has improved many of our players in his time, I would like Markovic to have a go rather than buying and making a loss on his sale. We will see.


21 Jun 2016 07:45:21
Markovic is a pacey wide player, so he is incomparable to Zielinski.

He is comparable to Mane though, and for all Mane's inconsistencies, he is still in a different league to Markovic. People seem to think Markovic is still a teenager. He's just turned 22 and he couldn't even score goals in Turkey. Ibe, Kent, Ojo and Canos are all ahead of him in terms of development and they are all younger. It is very unlikely we will even keep the 4 of them though, so it is very unlikely Markovic will be staying.

He needs a preseason worthy of the gods to save his career here.

I like the lad. He never moaned about being grossly misused by Brenda, but he just isn't good enough.


 
Change Consent