Liverpool Banter Archive January 09 2015

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.

09 Jan 2015 21:08:03
If sterling is out the squad supposedly. Is balotelli getting another shot? Or Borini? What would you guys prefer? I personally don't think balotelli is a lost cause, and even if we want to sell him, we have to play him. However, Borini will be a better fit for the way we want to play, and he can finish the lad!

Believable3 Unbelievable0

According to BennyC, Borini has the nod.

Agree0 Disagree0

10 Jan 2015 04:21:58
Think mario may not work out but is our best option and deserves more of a chance then he has been given!

But in fairness borini has never really been given a chance either so if benny is right ( which he has a good track record of being ) then good to see him given a chance! Not sure if him previously playing for Sunderland is good or not.

Agree1 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 20:08:22
sky sports are saying sterling is close to signing a new contract but driving home from work some one on said according to his source they are miles apart and he is no where near close to signing an extension. any one/ eds heard anything?

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - The expectation is that he will sign it.}

I have always felt that Sterling will sign another contract. He's at a big club getting more game time than he could dream of, I don't think he's at the stage to be demanding stupid money to stay.

Red Rum

Agree2 Disagree0

I think he's at the stage where there are many big clubs who would be in for him if he became available. Footballers careers are limited and youth these days are not patient and it's very hard to see where Raheem retires a Liverpool player.

Agree2 Disagree0

Happy that sterling will sign a knew deal, he deserves big money.
We need to keep the talent we have red rum and pay what he will get somewhere else if he leaves.
What is the reason behind all the remarks abt his wage? Age?
He is playing like a man pay him like a man.
Malta

Agree1 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 19:57:45
I haven't got it confirmed yet but I'm 90% sure that sterling is not in the squad for tomorrow's game.

Will post line up once I get the go.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

09 Jan 2015 20:15:09
Any particular reason for his absence if it's true? It will be a hard game and if we sit back they will be more than happy to take the game to us

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - He has been travelling.}

09 Jan 2015 20:44:49
The poor lamb. He must be tired.

Agree0 Disagree2

U heard any more on line up Benny? Always spot on

Agree1 Disagree0

The word is he's been in Jamaica for an extended period of rest.

Agree2 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 22:38:42
Mid season break to Jamaica. Can't be bad. Looks like borini starting. He will be well up for it tomorrow

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 23:33:48
So we are in a crisis, we let one of our best players go on the tank down Montego Bay, and in his place rely on a player we make no bones about the fact we don't want. Brendan Rodgers, you're a genius.

Agree3 Disagree3

10 Jan 2015 04:14:18
I hope he is with family there and they keep him in check. The thought of Raheem in Jamaican beaches alone worries me. Please behave lol.

Agree0 Disagree1

09 Jan 2015 19:42:40
Anfield is actually the new global headquarters of an evil wizrd that we know as Rodgers. Just as Gargamel needed smurfs to make lead into gold, the evil Rodgers requires footballers to be melted down into brilliant white paint for his teeth. This is why massed ranks of players disappear into Anfield never to be heard from ever again. Likewise the wheelbarrow loads of money that disappears - that is melted down into an orange paste for his skin.

Believable10 Unbelievable2

Poor Yesil :'(

Agree3 Disagree2

The conditions gargamel forces me to work under are very poor. we have been working on forming a union

Agree3 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 19:40:38
Eds I wonder if you can clear something up for me. All this talk of Mario being hawked around is not going to help his confidence at Liverpool. I have been looking at the stats for his last season at Milan 2013/14. Mario basically played up top in a front two, 41 games 18 goals. It is clear that he is no lone striker. With the above stats would you be happy to see him given a chance alongside Studge? I think we should stick with him and see how he gets on as part of a top two, maybe reassess at the end of the season?

Believable2 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - Clearly it has not worked out at Liverpool. If Rodger's wants to change tactics to accommodate him then that is entirely his decision.}

He scored 14 in Serie A proper last year with three of those being penalties and four being direct free kicks, so 7 from open play all season. He also took a ridiculous 152 shots to score those (by comparison, Sturridge took 99, scored 21).

I think you could stick him up front with whoever you want and, if he takes say 300 shots and takes all the penalties, he might bag 20 league goals.

Agree5 Disagree1

Have to agree with RDL here, as well as never having a stellar scoring record, look at wherever he's been and look how many goals are scored from free kicks, penalties and defensive errors. Then consider how many chances he wastes and how many pointless long shots he has, then consider how despite being the main man, free kick and penalty taker he only managed to score 17 goals in the serie A.

It was incredibly poor judgement by the comittee, one of the mos poorly judged signings any team has ever made.

Agree1 Disagree0

Fair call big Al, especially given BR modified his tactics to accommodate no-one on several occasions this season to a disastrous outcome.May as well try and get some benefit from changing tactics. Him and sturridge looked good the one game they played together.

Agree0 Disagree0

My favorite of all Anonymous Woolback- last season in Serie A, Balotelli took 95 shots outside the box and scored two that weren't from free kicks. That's just laughably awful.

Agree0 Disagree0

Agrred he takes a million shots per goal but why purchase him if you know he can't play up top on his own? The only way he can play to any degree is with a strike partner. I don't mind him taking shots as long as he puts some away, that was never going to happen whilst playing as a lone striker. I have always championed BR but I am left wondering what influence if any he has? And why can't he or his transfer commitee see the blatantly obvious when it comes to recruitment!

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 13:38:33
Hey Ed01, I'll cut this short but I'd love to help out with the site in any capacity, whether that be help editing or trying to find bugs to report,
Cheers mate.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed001's Note - what kind of thing were you thinking of mate? Not sure we need another Liverpool editor at the moment. Well other than when Ed002 is not about, then we do need one. But it is unfair to ask someone to just be there to cover those times! But if there is something else you would be interested in??}

If I had more time I could go through the dross for you. Always wanted to see some of the filth too x rated for the site. Lol

Agree1 Disagree0

{Ed001's Note - you wouldn't have time to even get a blimp at half of it mate!}

10 Jan 2015 02:05:31
Agree with mikey. Always have a curiosity for those posts which are cut at the start

Agree0 Disagree0

10 Jan 2015 13:20:45
I'd be quite happy to help editing any of the other football sites you have.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed033's Note - Emailed you, WelshBoyDave

09 Jan 2015 18:11:46
Considering the biggest chunk of the posts on this page is all about our poor defence and useless goalkeeper being the cause to our demise this first half of the season, I thought I'll do little comparison:

Last year after 20 games:
39 points, we conceded 23, scored 46, sitting pretty at 4th
This year after 20 games:
29 points, we conceded 27, scored 28, sitting average at 9th

Is it a new keeper what we need, or ist a striker to replace what we lost in the summer?

Believable1 Unbelievable1

If you seriously think it's a striker we need then wow

Agree1 Disagree0

A Keeper, a CB and maybe a DM

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 19:24:12
I think he has a valid point NOOH, we are clearly missing the goals that took us to 4th (or 2nd),
I doubt Roy is questioning out defence per say, just acknowledging our lack of goals compared to last season.

Agree2 Disagree0

Suarez and Sturridge where scoring for fun though and neither have featured much this year.
We don't need a striker, we need one or two of our many strikers to start scoring goals.

Agree0 Disagree0

What can you expect, Mikey? We only have seven strikers on staff, all bought by BR. Clearly we just need an 8th!

Agree4 Disagree0

Trying to replicate one of the highest scoring teams ever in the PL is a damn site harder than trying to shore up one of the highest conceding teams to ever finish second. Sort the defence out and we won't need to score 100 goals a season to finish top 4. That's starts with a keeper!

Agree1 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 18:06:00
Wish all this talk of Origi coming in will save our season would stop.

The kid is no closer to starting regularly than Jordan Ibe.

Give him a year or two and he'll be class, hopefully alongside Sterling and Ibe.

Just get Sturridge back fit alongside Balotelli, as was the original plan, and with sterling or Lallana just off them we'll be firing again.

Only priority in January, if Sturridge stays fit, is a keeper.Sort that out and we'll not be far away.

Believable2 Unbelievable0

He should stay on loan.

Agree3 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:31:30
Hi eds, Hope you're well

I know a deal with Lille about Origi is miles off, but if it were to go through then do you have any idea as to the role that club would provide to him? Would he go straight into the starting lineup or will BR use him more in rotation with the other strikers at the club

Thanks.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - He is far from ready for the EPL.}

Really? Jesus and the club are hell bent on bringing him in in January?

Agree1 Disagree0

He will be brendaned within 2 weeks of getting off the plane, he's not even playing well in france.

Agree1 Disagree1

10 Jan 2015 06:36:11
Completely agree with Ed002 on this, he is nowhere near ready, bringing him back is a mistake.

Agree0 Disagree0

10 Jan 2015 08:56:01
Too many fans clutching at straws thinking origi is the answer to all our problems, what we need is a settled team that knows what their supposed to be doing on the pitch and a manager to cop on and stop harping on about character after each game

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:34:42
Many people on here saying that we shouldn't be bringing Origi back because he is too young and its not fair to put him in, and i can see why people are saying this, but in my opinion it would be a great idea. This year we have only looked like a proper team when we have played with pace. Last year teams could not deal with our pace and the introduction of Sterling as a false 9 has improved recent performaces. This is my problem with Balotelli and Lambert, they don't bring enough pace to our attack (aswell as Balotelli be a lazy git). Origi will give us the pace we need, and with the lightning fast Sturridge still to come back, I think things may start to look better. Imo Origi suits our style far more than Borini, Lambert or Balo. don't forget that Origi is only a year younger than Can, Sterling and Markovic who are all now in our starting team.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

The benefit to getting him now for me is that he will have 6 months under his belt at Liverpool when next season comes around.
The fans are turning on him at Lille accusing him of already having his head in Liverpool.
That can't be good for a young player either.

Agree2 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:21:57
Eds, I just read from the Echo ......

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - We are not interested in tittle-tattle, but the goat was unhurt.}

09 Jan 2015 18:08:40
tittle-tattle Ed002, you're bad!! When was the last time I heard that?
No problems, just thought I should ask.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:17:39
Eminent Physiologist Dr Fraudian has diagnosed BR, s constant teeth whitening as a cry for help. He is literally baring his teeth at the world. The final act was to paint his face orange to further emphasis his glaring teeth. These stress action have not been helped by FSG insisting as he is only half good at his job ( i.e. good attack, bad defence) that he receive half of his pay. Thus removing his entire tooth whitening budget for the year causing further distress

Believable4 Unbelievable1

He shares notes with Tony Blair.
All teeth and trousers.
However Rodgers is not allowed to share Wendi Deng Murdoch. Blair's bit of fluff on the side.

Agree1 Disagree1

09 Jan 2015 14:44:51
Ed, I'm using the Ipad and when I load up the site, after a few seconds it directs me to a different page. It's like a popup but it opens up in this tab instead of a new one. Any idea why? Cheers.

Red Rum

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed033's Note - no, there is no redirect or popup that i know of

09 Jan 2015 17:32:06
Have you been on some dodgey sites in your alone time?

Agree4 Disagree0

Check if you've any free apps running in the background that are affecting your browser and pointing you to other ad related sites. When did this start happening and is there a particular "free app" that you downloaded just prior to this behaviour? If so, uninstall that app :)

Agree0 Disagree0

Keeps directing me to women's health sites? Pissing me off now!

Agree0 Disagree0

I don't normally shout "virus" for apple stuff as it's not that common, but it's possible. Have you tried a different browser? Have a look at Avira. It's free antivirus for apple stuff and pretty solid on Windows. I'm not sure about apple as I'm not a big fan of fruit based technology.

Agree0 Disagree0

Cheers mate, It's only since I switched from Virgin to BT, which was yesterday. It's a strange one.

Red Rum

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 16:01:55
Hi Eds,

Firstly, thanks for all the continuing good work you do. It must be tough listening to all the endless questions that appear here and you each deserve a great deal of credit for taking the time to reply.

You've mentioned a few times that Rodger's interactions with the press have upset the club heirarchy quite abit. I'm just wondering if you could maybe shed a little more light on what he's saying that's causing problems?

I'm just not sure I understand the issue, is he just saying stupid things that the club would rather he remained silent about?

Many Thanks

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - Done to death.}

09 Jan 2015 15:17:36
Why would world class players now come to liverpool ? Absolutely no chance ! Its not something emotional, its totally practical !

Why would they come to Liverpool to work with an arrogant, useless manager ? Rather they would choose to work with world class managers like pep, mou, pelegrini, arsene, van gaal etc.

1 year back there may well be a chance when we had luis suarez, gerrard .But now who would come to play with allen, lambert, borini, origi .

So sorry Mr.Rodgers ! You can forget about world class talents rather bring at what you are best ! Allen, Borini . . .

Believable6 Unbelievable1

When did we ever buy world class talent?

Agree3 Disagree0

I think people expect/want us to be competing with say United and Bayern for signings when in reality we're more in the position to be competing with Spurs and BVB. It's just the reality of the situation, sadly.

We need to be smarter about who we buy, we need to be smarter about how we play, and we need to be smarter about increasing revenue so we don't have to rely so much on being smarter.

Agree2 Disagree0

Thats not the club we are we don't buy world class stars we make them when we bought Torres Suarez Mascherano and Alonso they made their name playing for us you may in a few years consider Markovic Can and Sterling World class players

Agree5 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 16:41:16
We SELL world class players because people in charge of our club don't share the ambition of the fans 'to be the best.
We all still follow Shankleys dream,, whereas the men at the top never will

Agree1 Disagree1

09 Jan 2015 17:05:43
World class players cost the money in which I'm so grateful our club do not intend to pay.

Leave that to your Utd's, City's and Chelsea.

Agree2 Disagree2

C'mon Mr Rodgers. Buy some more overpriced cast-offs. They all see us coming now.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 20:15:26
Van Gaal? Why would any world class player want to play for someone who looks like E.T.?

Agree1 Disagree0

RDL is on the money! We make world class players and not the other way around. Go ask Suarez, Torres and the rest if they wish they never left us. As for Suarez, he is prob wishing he was still at Anfield and at a club where the fans loved him so much. We will not be buying WC players for stupid prices and I`m cool with that. We are in the BVB mould now and if done well, we can have as much success as they have.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 14:47:10
eds reds I've just been having a look around different sites, lfc mentioned concerning ter stegan, it seems he's unhappy at barca, no starts ets, possible loan? also illay gundongen of dortmund, refusing new contrat, 16 million? would be a great signing, i know dream on!!!.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - I would not get your hopes up.}

09 Jan 2015 14:22:02
Is it just me or has Rogers at the beginning of the season put his hopes on sturridge been the pin of the attack and been absaloutly rapid up top ? If you think studge, sterling, ballo, Markovic are absaloutly quick as hell and would scare even the quickest of cb never mind the sluggish ones I maybe clutching at straws here but when he's back I think this season just may turn round

Believable3 Unbelievable0

I feel it's clutching at straws myself. I do see your point though. With Sturridge up top we'd definitely solve our lack of goals problem. However, we are still a mess without the ball and defending set pieces is just a shambles.

Agree3 Disagree1

09 Jan 2015 14:31:19
Undoubtedly I feel he was looking to Sturridge to be our focal point this season. Despite his injury record, there's no chance anyone realistically saw him missing half the season. His presence and ability will help us for sure. I think it'll certainly give sterling a bit more life as he may have more space to work in.

I won't sit here and claim he'll change our fortunes because that's a lot of pressure on his shoulders and he will need to gain match fitness. But just maybe he can slowly play a part in creating a bit of hope back around the club.

Agree1 Disagree1

In order for us to make top 4 would require a minimum of about 70 points. That is 2.28 points per game. Last season we averaged 2.21 points per game with the most deadly strike force in the league.

Sturridge may help us to get more goals but top 4 is nothing but a pipe dream.

Agree1 Disagree4

09 Jan 2015 15:03:43
Max but it's a completely different season pal we scored over a 100 goals last season and didn't win the league no team battling for top 4 bar city and Chelsea are playing great United are scraping wins by some sort of luck arsenal to be honest are playing poor and spurs ain't much better anything can happen mate

Agree2 Disagree1

Nobody knows exactly how the league will pan out, only it will probably be between city and Chelsea for the title then who knows, surely utd's luck will run out, maybe Southampton fall away, and the usual top 4 finish for arsenal?

Agree1 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 15:39:01
When we had Suarez and Sturridge, if one was injured or suspended or whatever we still had the other, so for virtually the whole of last season, at least one the two played in every single game and a lot of the time both of them, The problem now is wee only have Sturridge - and when he's not there, such as now, we have nothing. Leaking goals is a problem as well, but we leaked goals last season and got away with it because we scored more. This season we don't score. Sturridge may - if he hits the ground running- keep us in the Europa League placings, but he is not enough to get us in the Champions League placings.

Agree1 Disagree0

I think the issue is the defense only we relied on the goals so much last season because our defense was a shambles even chelsea did okay last season considering their striking options because they defend so well so if we learn to defend we can reach top four and get our goals from sterling lallana and Sturridge

Agree0 Disagree0

No chance top 4 i'm afraid we're too inconsistent an a very poor defence

Agree2 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:53:36
Big E, speak for yourself mate. I Could see this season being disaster a mile off.
The Boys an enigma but with his injurys he's a liability. Wouldn't rule him out of another spell on the sidelines after his return, infact I'd put money on it sadly

Agree2 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 19:40:14
Fair enough Dbol. As I said we knew/know of his injury record and that he's frail, but despite this I and I suspect many others, didn't expect him to miss such a large proportion as he has. I would have expected 1-2 months in small doses with little knocks. But not such a long term absence!

I just hope he clicks into gear ASAP and does the business whilst he is fit!

Agree0 Disagree0

To be fair, if we have players upfront who the opposition are scared of then does that not help our defence?

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 22:05:37
Same mate, I think he will, he's got great understanding with Coutinho and I can see him scoring from the off.
Would you sign a goal scorer Big E? I would, Balo Lambert Borini and even Origi aren't going to score the goals we lack when Sturridge is out.

Agree0 Disagree0

I'd definitely sign another striker, Balo and Lambert don't have the pace or runs of Sturridge, so it changes our style of play when he's out (note how Coutinho came back to life when we put Sterling up top, but we need another killer finisher). Lacazette or Berahino would be my picks from the rumours.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 14:06:48
I don't what is actually wrong about our transfers, we don't seem to attract players of high calibre anymore and we do waste time in pursuing our targets while others gazing us in the market. We have identify a weak link in the current team which is the goal keeper. There are quality players out there, we should go for one because by summer we would have teams with more financial muscle to contend with. As far as am concern for the recent transfers made, January business has always favored Liverpool as a club. YMWA

Believable6 Unbelievable1

Which qualtiy keepers are out there, please tell me? And who is a realistic option.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 14:51:15
Well to be honest, I feel like we were never the team that are filled with world class players and sign top top players. Our legends are either home grown players or they are the one who became world class playing for us. Don't get me wrong but since I started watching Liverpool that has always been the case. We have had few bad signing and few that has not gone in our support yet though.

Agree1 Disagree0

Maybe that is why we haven't won a league in over 20 years,

Agree5 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 13:16:37
Has anyone else noticed that Balo is nearly always smiling or laughing on the LFC official training ground photos yet whenever he's on the pitch in a proper game, he looks like he can't be arsed. .

Believable7 Unbelievable0

He's a happy guy. Wish he looked happier on the pitch. It's there where he looks bored

Agree4 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 17:56:45
It's all an act. Walks around like all eyes are on him and he cannot perform. I bet in a game, if the stadium was empty and the cameras off, he'd run around and TRY and probably be one of the best players on the pitch

Agree1 Disagree2

09 Jan 2015 13:08:19
Hello eds. This great work your doing could not be more appreciated thank you!!
Based on all your previous edits, I came to the understanding that offloading players is the only probable move that could perhaps be done by LFC.
If that is true. who are the players that may probably leave LFC??
My sincerest regards

Believable1 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - If you have read all of the previous posts I would think you would know that Suso and Lucas were the players who have been actively looking for new opportunities. I have also explained that Balotelli has been offered to clubs in Italy and England but no one has shown an interest in buying him.}

Since Balotelli has been offered around, does he himself want to leave liverpool or is this Liverpool trying to get rid and hence sending the agents around? Thanks

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - Liverpool contacted Balotelli's representative and told them to try to find a buyer - unfortunately the price wanted by Liverpool is well beyond what anyone would be willing to pay. Ergo, we are where we are.}

09 Jan 2015 16:40:44
Balotelli is probably a scapegoat here. I still think if played in the right position(upfront with Sturridge), he will get us many goals. And there were many games in which he was the best player on the pitch(when we couldn't get a shot on target, he was the only one making decent attempts).
He is not the kind of player who can play alone upfront, let alone with players around him who can't make a decent pass.

Agree6 Disagree1

I`m with you, Pirate. Balo was a handful for Spurs when he played along w/ Studge and Sterling vs Spurs. That was not a flash in the pan. We were all salivating at the prospect of those two causing chaos in the PL. That player is still there and that formation can still work. Playing him in situations where he will fail and using him as a scapegoat each time we don`t win will not help because based on the crap he has gone thru in his life growing up, abuse will not affect him because he is simply used to it. He has looked sharp and gotten into good positions in the last few games YET doesn`t get any credit even for the smallest things he does right (don`t see Lambo getting stalked and humiliated by the media for having poor games and not scoring) and people berate him because their minds are already made up that the poor boy can`t do anything right. If I was him, I wouldn`t give a crap either because all I get is blame and abuse so there`s no point caring. He needs encouragement and reassurances which is what Prandelli did and he is still the only coach to make Balo shine YET. Prandelli who I like) knew how to reach him, protect and motivate him an he also knew that unlike the dictators (Mou and Mancini), abuse and tyranny will not affect him because he is extremely tough mentally so such tyranical tactics will not work with him. Hence IMO, play Balo w/ Studge or Studg w/ Balo and Sterling, support him and let him know he will and can help us and we will see improvement, IMO.

Agree2 Disagree0

10 Jan 2015 18:08:42
In the game today, Borini was absent most of the time. At least Balotelli gave them something to be afraid of.
But the people will speak of his slip. Typical stuff.

Agree0 Disagree0

Exactly!

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 12:35:25
From what I've heard there will be no one coming in this window.

I've also heard in the summer that Rodgers will only be looking at free transfers coming in(and they always work out well don't they. voronin, Cole, etc).

Rodgers is looking at Milner, Delph and Ruddy.

The summer window is possibly going to be the most depressing transfer window since the one where Joe Cole and Paul Konchesky joined us.

Bearing in mind the players Rodgers would like to move on don't have any takers, we are in a complete mess.

Believable2 Unbelievable3

Milner will definitely stay at City.

Delph would be a good squad player.

Ruddy would be backwards from Mingolet.

I agree though, this summer looks grave indeed. If we could trust Rodger to give Ibe, Origi, Rossiter, Teixeira, Ilori, Wisdom, Ojo, Smith, McLaughlin etc a chance though, we wouldn't need to sign anyone other than a couple of goalkeepers, one midfielder and a world class centre back. We're not short of attacknig options. They're just all injured, on loan or sat in the academy thinking "could i really do any worse?!"

Agree4 Disagree9

EMS, why another CB? We already have 3 quality ones in Sakho, Lovren and Ilori with Toure as mentor. Just sell Skrtel and give the above 4 a chance before splurging on an already overstocked position. These players will undoubtedly improve once a proper manager comes in. Like u said, give young players a chance and buy a top notch GK, CF and CDM and next season could be much much better than this one.

Agree3 Disagree2

I'd sell Skrtel and Toure. That would leave Sakho, Lovren as senior centre backs. Ilori should definitely be given the odd chance, but Lovren looks like a rabbit in headlights right now and Ilori and Sakho might not want to stay after the way they've been treated.

I just think we need to break the bank and sign a world class partner for Sakho. Lovren could well play alongside Sakho under a better manager and coaching team though. In that case, yes save the money.

Agree0 Disagree2

{Ed002's Note - Toure is out of contract in the summer.}

Indian Buzzer, Kolo Toure will be out of contract this summer and I think we're pinning too much on Ilori. My guess is he'll also be a summer departure.

Agree0 Disagree0

I'm getting a bit bored with saying this but EMS, you are spot on again

Agree2 Disagree2

09 Jan 2015 17:17:36
Milner will leave.

He knows he will get the money he demands but I suspect that the money is not an issue now (why would it after his numerous lucrative moves and the wealth at the club).

This lad is a grafter on the pitch since he was a kid and I suspect it's the game time which is an issue. He's probably waiting to see how many other players come into City.

Anyway, he might as well come to Liverpool with his England team-mates as it makes so much sense for the player and Liverpool. Come to speak of it, there's a scary amount of England players at our club, with many more full internationals to come.

I never considered it at the time but the more I think about it, the more I realise it would be an outstanding move for all parties (except City of course).

There's no smoke without fire on this one I'm afraid.

Agree0 Disagree0

Milner is text book mediocre, he has Downing mk two written all over him. Depressing times.

Agree1 Disagree0

It might be a blessing in disguise.
Any plan which allows us to test the youngsters to see if they can hack it is fine by me.
Delph would be a good signing in my opinion.

Agree0 Disagree1

Delph ain`t that good and we have players who are better than he is. We should be playing them instead of buying players to complete a squad. That is what the academy should b for.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 12:29:49
Can anyone confirm how Jerome Sinclair is developing? Have not been able to see any recent games he may have featured in sadly.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Very well but It doesn't matter brendan won't give him a chance in the first team at all anyway . unfortunately

Agree0 Disagree1

09 Jan 2015 11:57:40
Hi Eds,

I wanted to ask about FSG reviewing the position of the manager and coaching staff. I assume they have surrounded themselves with people with a decent knowledge of football and have sought advice regarding transfer matters, the manager and coaching staff. Any idea who these 'football' people are and the general advice that they have been giving?

Ed002 wrote not that long ago, "There will be some dependency on what happens with the management."
Is it expected that Rodgers will be sacked and replaced at the end of the season or will there be meetings in which Rodgers will be given an ultimatum (e.g. receive help with coaching, take on additional coaches)?

The reason I ask is I fear if we change manager again it will just stall our progression as a team. I understand Rodgers has his faults (every manager does) but he is still a young coach who is learning and developing the team and last year we saw some of the most entertaining football the club has seen in a long long time (Suarez and Sturridge obviously played a massive part).

Finally I wanted to ask about John Achterberg as he arrival coincided with Pepe Reina's downturn in form. I don't solely blame JA for this by the way as I think Pepe's head was already turned but none of the other goalkeepers he has coached have improved (they seemed to have become worse). Are there plans to replace him either by Rodgers (if he is still manager) or the board? I have asked coaches within the game that I know about JA and they don't seem to criticize his coaching which is fine but given our poor success with goalkeepers (transfers could be blamed for this too) whilst he has been here, it makes me wonder.

Apologies for the length of this message but I'd rather not see people sacked (I'm a hypocrite for wanting John Achterberg replaced I know!) and then a raft of new players and coaches brought in and then be in the same situation again in 2-3 years!

Cheers Eds.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - I have explained before that I am not going to get in to naming names as it will lead to abuse, but the owners are continuing to work through the entire business and have already made significant changes in certain areas.

As for Rodgers it has been done to death. The expectation was that Liverpool would be challenging for the EPL and the Champions League and vast amounts of money have been spent by the owners to try and achieve that. Much of the money has been spent at the behest of Rodgers who made promises that the club has not come close to achieving.}

Jay jay, I don't know if you have seen JA in the warm ups at Anfield on match days but he can hardly run, it seems he has had an injury in the past, he has a very lopsided run, it makes me wonder how he can coach by demonstrating something he wants a keeper to do as oppose to just telling him, in all the years watching him do warm ups I can't recall seeing him in between the sticks, he just seems to boot the ball to the keeper to practice catches. I know some coaches have never been pro's but JA was a pro goalie, seems a strange to me.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 16:55:35
Cheers for the response Ed, I understand that naming names would only cause trouble. With regards to Rodgers, I can only assume every managers makes unrealistic 'promises' and I still believe he should be given more time.

18and5, I completely agree with you regarding JA at match days. All he does is punt a ball up to the keeper! I don't know whether this is practice for long balls and crosses that will happen during a game but none of our current keepers can deal with a cross which raises the question, what are they doing in training!? The reason I've zoned in on JA is I believe he's got the job because he was a decent keeper (albeit in league 1) but I haven't seen anyone improve under his guidance. Bring back Xavi Valero!

Cheers,

Agree1 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - The owners want success and have put the money in to transfers and built enormous debt for the club. Rodgers is not good enough and they are well aware of that.}

That's fair enough Ed.
Do you know if Rodgers is aware his days are numbered (or at least his position is less than secure)? I understand no managers' position is fully secure but he should surely be aware of the ongoing review by FSG? Is it a case of try to do the best he can and hope he does enough to keep his job or wait till they decide to give him the sack so he can get that big pay check.

By the way has FSG's review only come about due to Liverpool's poor showing this season or have they had reservations about Rodgers anyway? If so, why offer him a new contract?

Cheers,

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - He is aware that the owners have been reviewing the entire business and making changes.}

Great posts, Jay Jay! BTW, are you from Naija?

Agree0 Disagree0

10 Jan 2015 11:20:13
Thanks for your responses Ed.

Thanks redohio, I'm not from Nigeria sorry, Augustine was just my favourite player to watch.

Cheers,

Agree0 Disagree0

He is a god in Nigeria.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 11:46:57
Eds if Lucas leaves this month for a fee, do u think there will be a replacement lined up?
Even tho we have a bunch of central midfielders, none of them can really do the defensive role.

Believable1 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - Search engine.}

09 Jan 2015 11:27:04
Not to spin the pessimist wheel, but I do recall Rodgers stating we wouldn't be doing any business in January, which leads me to believe we won't be doing any business (except perhaps selling players). Last year he said we were looking "for the right players" and we added nobody (Konoplyanka myth irrelevant to me). Unless this is a new tactic to lower expectations, I am really not expecting anything from January except perhaps a sale of Borini or Baoltelli (not both). I worry if we don't sign a keeper. That is my only real concern. Migs is simply not good enough, and the defence needs a world beater between the sticks right now. Lack of improvement in that position will be a massive statement by the club (ie. "we realize that we have no keeper, but the financial situation is such that we can do nothing about it, irrespective how dire the situation").

Believable3 Unbelievable0

09 Jan 2015 11:24:28
Gone already Ed's? How long was that post up for, 20 minutes or so? Some people who frequent this side need a personality transplant, they also need to look up the definition of the word BANTER!

You have enough nonsense to sort through on this site Ed's so I will make this my last post and save you even more hassle. Good luck with the site Ed's hope you attract some decent posters who can take a joke and banter and not just ask you banal questions about are we signing so and so for the 300th time that day. Take care lads and lasses.

Believable3 Unbelievable2

{Ed002's Note - Yep.}

Don't worry Waro, half of the threads I comment on end up being deleted becaue of trolling. I've just leanred to take it as a compliment now! There is a famous Winston Churcill quote that goes:
"You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life."

Better to be hated than jump on the bandwagon! Keep posting mate. I don't always agree with you, but this sie would be boring if all the 'No.1 fans' hounded people off the site.

Agree0 Disagree8

09 Jan 2015 14:27:51
With EMS on this! What's the point of a banter page were we're supposed to debate issues if everyone has the same opinion? It's a difference of opinions between us all that makes this page worth visiting.

If people can't handle it if someone disagrees then that's their problem, not yours. I've seen some of your posts, sure you may be a bit abrasive, but you stand up for what you believe, whether or not I agree doesn't mean you should be forced to possibly stop posting!

Agree0 Disagree0

Feel free to post on the banter site (link at top) Waro. We have a little more time than the other Eds, and I'm quite happy to remove the abuse whilst trying to let reasonable replies through. .

Agree0 Disagree0

You would be missed Waro.
Don't allow them to silence your opinions fella.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 11:11:32
Do you expect Liverpool to have scouts watching the Asian Cup in Australia.
or do scouts not watch whole tournaments, just individuals.

I ask this as I believe Matt Ryan is the perfect fit for what Liverpool need as a goalkeeper. He is a presence in his box, vocal and is great at starting counter attacks.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - I have no doubts that there will be someone representing Liverpool there.}

Completely agree. Mat Ryan looks good. Haven't heard of any interest from us though.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 11:06:17
My God what happened to giving players from the academy a chance? I'm disappointed my favourite player Suso is gone without being given a decent run of games.

Add to that the fact that there was no plan to loan out the players that were loaned, and very little follow up and plan for their development.

In the summer after we sold Kris Petersen i was surprised as he was consistently one of the best players in the academy, we loaned out Ibe when this would have been his break out season, 20 year old Teixeira was also loaned out in a move i don't think makes much sense.

I follow the academy and think we have a good bunch of youngsters but after seeing Pertersen and now Suso sold i really can't see the likes of Kent, Wilson, Dunn, Teixeira, Canos being given a chance either. Youngsters like Ward have also not been given a chance in the cups when it has seemed logical to do so

This to me is evidence of the mismanagement that will continue to hold this club back. Hopefully it changes but i just don't see it

Cheers

Believable13 Unbelievable0

Best post this year mate.

Agree3 Disagree5

09 Jan 2015 12:28:01
Good post. This is a debate I really enjoy partaking in, as I've had experience within a pro academy as a coach.

Firstly, I'll admit I was surprised Peterson got shipped out after a decent pre season. Suso, an obvious talent but without knowing the ins and outs, I can only assume he lacks application in some form.

The other thing with Suso, considering our squad is full with attacking midfield players, where does he really fit? He's not better than Coutinho who still has potential to fulfil! Many see sterling as best in the 10? So we end up playing him out of his favoured position, again something fans disagree with. Unfortunately, this for me is a lose-lose. It's just a shame we couldn't get a fee.

Let us not forget the age of the likes of Wilson etc too, there is still plenty of time. They're still developing in every aspect of their game. But the likes of; Wilson, Sinclair, Kent, Chirivella, Rossiter, Brannagan. Just a few, definitely all have the potential to be able to make it here.

And one final note, and I realise this shouldn't necessarily matter, but it does.

Squad size, there is just no way we can bring up 5 or so players and give them adequate game time. Personally I agree with loans for developing players, I just wish in future, unlike with Ibe and Texeira, that it is with other prem sides.

The only disappointment from this side of things and giving youngsters a chance, is that Sinclair or Yesil (am I right in thinking he's fit again?) haven't at least been making the bench if we have been so desperately short of a striking option.

I know many want to see our young uns coming through, I'm the same. I just don't think it's so cut and dry as throwing them in, particularly as we aren't exactly flying at the moment.

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 13:44:55
Best time to chuck youngsters in, is when the side is confident and playing well and you can't really say that atm, can you? I worry about the young ones too, as at times all we seem to want to do is buy yet more players for said positions, when we have them in the club already, thus making our wage bill even higher and ending up with frustrated kids!

Agree0 Disagree0

Very good post kawabanga. The Kristoff Peterson sale left me shocked as well. The same kid that score in nearly every pre season game he played was dumped out for a small compensation. The management really needs to buck up, we cannot have more talented players being flogged for meagre sums and buying big money replacements who are no better.

Agree2 Disagree0

Lads I;m not being funny, I think the youth aren't being given a chance, but at the same time we have every 1 on here saying These players are class and will bring Liverpool forward:
Ojo
Wisdom
Kelly
peterson
Flanno
Robbo(when he was younger)
sterling
Ibe
Yesil
Dunne
Rossiter
Lloyd Jones
wilson
trickett smith
Mclaughlin
texeira
suso

I'm sorry but not all of these players constantly bandied about are going to make the grade, do they deserve chances in cups, sure then again you want trophies, and playing the youth in these cups might get you knocked out.

That's 14 players I have listed that people want to be itnegrated through the academy within the next 3 years or so. I'm sorry but not all are going to make it, and the way we talk about them, it has to be said surely there's a chance we are overstating some if not a lot of their potentials

I cite Robbo in this case who, 3/4 years ago every 1 was raving about after his appearance vs arsenal etc.

you are looking at us having a 100% successful 1st team rate with our 14 or so academy players I've mentioned, I'm sorry, but it's just not going to happen.

Agree3 Disagree0

I agree with Bobatron completely. Posters wax lyrical about our youth squad but if 2 maybe 3 got regular first team football then that would be tremendous success. As i have said before, let's see where they are in 5 years time even if not at Lfc. My guess is Championship maybe lower PL football if they are lucky. I will put my hat on Suso not having a great carrer at AC Milan before moving to a lesser team in Spain and McLaughlin carving out a career in League 1.

Agree1 Disagree1

Think i am 50/50 with Bobatron, sure we can't play too many of our youngsters, as itb would upset the balance of the team, but, there are games, say this season, that we are never going to win, let's say nearly all against the top six, we could give game time to one of the young players on that list,
this could save us millions if it worked out, we have wasted millions and more millions this last few years,
just hoping that Sturridge will be the one to spark us back were we belong, we have lacked a proper striker since he got injured,
Sterling is much better coming in behind the striker, at speed .

Agree0 Disagree1

After Robbo's game against Arsenal did he get a run of games? No.
I want the shirt to go to a player who comes into the side and grabs the opportunity with both hands.
Robbo did that against Arsenal a few years back and then he was discarded and then loaned out.
Suso, the same.
Even Williams and Rossiter this year have not been seen since coming in and playing well.
I understand that not every player will make it but we don't really give them an opportunity to make it and that is the whole point in the academy.
There are loads of posts relating to how we have messed up in the transfer market wasting millions of pounds.
We are also wasting millions by not utilizing the academy in the right way.
We should be sponsored by a waste management company.

Agree1 Disagree0

If we've learnt anything recently it's that Robbo isn't anywhere enar the level required we found that out when we loaned him.

Agree0 Disagree0

It takes courage and resolve to play youth and believe in them. See Southampton. Courage is what BR lacks and only plays youth (Sterling, Ibe, Flanno, Wisdom) because he had no choice and not because he really wanted to as he is quick to take the credit when they succeed and looks to dump them and buy players from other academies to take their place. Also, the fact that they all won`t ake it is NO reason not to play them at all and stick with them even if they fail in their first game(s). That is a lame excuse and a complete cop-out. If that was the case, Barca, Ajax, Bayern, and even Real Marid would not have given us Raul, Cassillas, Mata, Negredo, Jesse Iniesta, Messi, Pujol, Pep, Van Basten, the De Boer twins, Davids, Kluivert, Lahm, Alaba, Hummels and. Emre Can just off the top of my head. You have to be commited to playing youth and it is either you are or you aren`t and BR is NOT.

Agree1 Disagree0

But how many players didn't make the grade? The point still stands, NOT every player currently being touted as our fans as ''good enough''is igoing to actually be good enough

Agree1 Disagree0

AGAIN, wrong argument! You must not have read the whole post because you missed the part where I said "You have to have the resolve to play them and take a chance on them" and let the chips fall where they may. The fact is you have to give them a decent shot to know if they are or are not good enuff to make the grade. AGAIN, not playing them because they all might not make it is a lame excuse and a weak argument for not giving them any shot of actually making it. That is the attitude BR has. They are all not going to make it at LFC so why bother trying? PATHETIC attitude, IMO! Those who make it, make it and those who don`t? Well, dont. Really don`t care how much you are touted as a youth player because even veterans are highly-rated and still couldn`t make the grade regardless of how many chances they were given. In our position, playing the kids and giving them a chance is our best shot at getting good players for peanuts like Sterling (who is proven already), Wisdom (very experienced in the PL already) as well as Tex and IBE who are VERY promising) to add to Dunn, Jones, Wilson and Ojo who are very highly-rated by those who have seen them play countless times. We will never know who will make it IF they are not given a fair shot.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed007's Note - If they don't make it at Liverpool just sell them on, you'll always get 3/4 million for any player with a bit of EPL expereience from teams like Stoke, WBA or Crystal Palace.}

I agree with REDOHIO here. Obviously we are not going to bring 10 players through at the same time. There has to be a balance! There are too many apologists among us. Always putting out the same old rubbish, they are to young, they need more time, blah, blah, blah. IMHO that is a load of B*ll*x. I am sick and tired of hearing it. Southampton would be a non-league club by now without their commitment to youth. Even with Money to spend they are still actively promoting youth players.We have some serious talent available to us. Unfortunately they will not develope any further without Prem/top league game time. Robo against Arsenal was mentioned above. Someone said "look how he did on loan". EXACTLY. instead of building on his momentum and developing him next to Agger and with a world class Captain in Gerrard, we dropped him then loaned him to a lower league! Maybe he would not have made it, but we will never know because we mis-managed him. The biggest crime BR can commit this window will be if he let's Lucas go and does not use Rossiter! Yes he is a kid and will make a few mistakes (Gerrard has made more than a few this season), BUT he is ready NOW! Our loans of IBE and TEXEIRA were useless. They will not really develop at the clubs they were sent too. They need to return to us asap and get first team games. They too are ready IMO. The constant mis-management of our youth system and the tired old excuses (management and fans) used to justify NOT playing youth, are p*ssing me off. If BR the self proclaimed messiah of youth football doesn't change then he needs to take a walk and allow us to bring in someone who is am ore experienced and all rounded coach, and will work with youth. Rant over

Agree1 Disagree0

So we should play every single youth player in the first team at some point is what you're saying?

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 10:26:17
hello eds.

i know that Stevie won't be here for next season, one thing which i don't understand is how Pirlo who does not do any dirty work just does what actually Stevie does for us is still able to play for Juventus.

thanks eds.

Believable0 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - You do understand that people are different?}

Pirlo is a completely different type of player, playing in a slower league and has others around him that allow him to play, he has Pogba and Vidal, Gerrard has Joe Allen. That's the difference.

Agree5 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 11:06:35
Players around him help, but he's far better tactically. That is why he can still pull strings for Juve.

One thing that should be clear to everyone is that positionally and tactically Stevie isn't a DM. And he just doesn't have the legs for higher up the pitch on regular basis.

It's time to let go, he'll always be a club legend and was one of the best. But it's time to move on.

Agree6 Disagree0

Mr Dennis hahaha that made me chuckle

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 16:48:32
The difference is Pirlo's doing the same job he always did and was always world class at. Gerrard was never world class at sitting in front of the back four, either to protect it, or to be the man to take the bulk of the passes from the defence and build the play from the back.

Gerrard was world class given a free role to find space in the top third to create and score goals. He was as much of a threat for goals and assists as any "traditional" no. 10 or second striker, like Kaka or Totti, and he had the energy and strength to give more to the team's in the general build-up and when they lost the ball than they did. At his peak, there wasn't really a player who played like him, much less one who was as good as him.

Pirlo couldn't turn around at 36 and do what Gerrard used to do, any more than Gerrard can suddenly start doing Pirlo's job effectively at 34. It really boggles me why people thought he could.

Agree3 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 07:11:12
"Marquee" signings - i'm not a fan - main reason is that i believe that once a person achieves top status/success you lose your hunger and drive (its a natural thing) its interesting that if we look at Torres, Suarez and Sturridge - they all had huge potential and still plenty to prove to the world - hunger made them what they became here. I am not sure our answer is signing a "marquee" player

Replacing Gerrard - need a young, aggressive, player with clear potential and hunger ;-)

I think to find that player will cost as at the very least 30-40 Mil.

Where we find someone with his authority and composure I'm not sure.

Question to ends: Who would you buy if you were not limited in anyway to replace the Gerrard effect in the team?

Believable2 Unbelievable1

{Ed001's Note - I would give the players we have a chance to step up and instead but a top class keeper. Build from the back.}

Ed001 how about Ter Stegan reports are saying were in for him, he's a top quality young keeper i mentioned this the other day.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed001's Note - Barca have a transfer ban, they are unlikely to be willing to consider losing him mate. Not this window anyway.}

BigD, i very much doubt Ter Stegen would take such a big step backwards from challenging for la liga to fighting for a top 6 finish in the premier league. He will have better options if Barca do let him go.

Agree1 Disagree0

I'd say top class keeper, top class defensive midfielder and a top class striker. I think the defenders we have can be top class, but they have been constantly exposed by weak midfield and having a poor keeper behind them doesn't help.

Agree1 Disagree2

Even if "top class" keepers or defenders are signed I think we'll still be in the same situation with Rodgers as manager.

Agree1 Disagree0

Yes, your right, ....nonsense deleted due to ignorant so called "fan" giving abusive names to Liverpool players - the levels of disrespect are truly astonishing....

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 12:33:35
Indian, Ter Stegen is not challenging for La Liga, he is sitting on the bench of a team that is challenging for La Liga, big difference. That said I doubt we would get him due to the transfer ban, but would still love it!

Agree0 Disagree0

Just to reply to big Q from Big A, who would you buy to replace Stevie G, well I have said it before, we already have that player, Emre Jackie Can, what a player this lad will turn out to be, as long as our current manager doesn't mess with his playing time,
this 3/4/3 formation works for me, now we have to play our best players in their best positions,
this plus Sturridge scoring lots of goals, will take us up the league, how far, not sure, as lots of teams are as hot and cold as we are .

Agree0 Disagree0

Ter Steggen is aweful and I would not touch him at all as he has shown he cannot hack it at a big club. There are good keepers out there especially in Ligue 1 like Costil (rennes), Ruffier(Saint Etienne), Mandanda (Marseilles) as well as in Germany like Leno and Zeiller. The scouting dept is not doing it`s job because if I can name these keepers because I`ve seen them play a lot especially in the French league so WTF are they doing. GET TO WORK!

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - That is not how it works. They are scouting players who may be of interest and available and you are playing fantasy football.}

Maybe, Ed! Still feels good tho. lol!

Agree0 Disagree0

I'll be glad to be rid of the 'Gerrard effect', as you call it.

Yet you seem to value this 'Gerrard effect' at £40m to replace!

This is an example of the media messing with people's heads.

Gerrard is a legend and a celebrity, but in reality, we are losing a poor DM player - and saving a fortune in wages.

Just play Lucas at DM- where he should have been playing all along - and we'll have a better side. Or give others a chance - I wholeheartedly agree with ed001's comment on this.

The other players would struggle to do any worse at DM tbh!

Agree0 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 05:17:53
So long Zaf you will be missed. Loved the fact you never smiled and just got on with your work in a meticulous and conscientious way. Shame some of your patients didn't follow your lead. Good luck in your next chapter Doc.

Believable2 Unbelievable0

08 Jan 2015 21:54:36
HI eds your doing a great job as per usual

Are we in for anyone or is the finance the exits free up going to determine who we bring in.
I think we are in between a rock and a hard place TBH,
what we got to sell/loan and what we need,

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed001's Note - it is sell to buy, mostly, right now.}

09 Jan 2015 00:27:56
First Gerrard and now Dr. Zaf Iqbal gone. There are now no legends left at our club anymore. Dr Zaf always reminded me of Penfold from Danger Mouse, just thought I'd share that thought.

Believable5 Unbelievable0

09 Jan 2015 00:09:23
Assaidi to Dubai in next few weeks £3million

Believable1 Unbelievable0

09 Jan 2015 20:07:16
Must be a private jet, because even first class wouldn't cost more than a few grand

Agree0 Disagree0

08 Jan 2015 22:15:37
So Zaf Iqbal is the first casualty of the previously mentioned investigation of how the club is run from top to bottom? Are there bigger changes on the way?

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - Far from the first.}

09 Jan 2015 00:57:28
Have you noticed that no matter what combination of centre backs we have we still end up conceding game after game? Does this not tell you something? The reason our centre backs are always under pressure is down to having poor central midfielders who don't provide adequate defensive cover and who don't know how to recycle possession effectively.

No matter how you put it Gerrard isn't physically capable to provide adequate cover for our defence, likewise he isn't physically capable to carry the ball forward or create space for himself. He is often forced into long ball passes which as we know is frustrating and isn't very effective.

Allen is too lightweight (as we know). He isn't comfortable on the ball and he doesn't have the physicality to help protect the defence. Over two years at the club and no improvement (even when he has had a run of games he hasn't taken his chance).

Henderson does the defensive stuff well. He closes players down and gets in front of the opposing attackers to help protect the defence, however he is not the best passer of the ball and doesn't have the intelligence/vision to play the central midfield role. For me his best position is right midfield (behind Lallana in the pecking order)

Lucas is the best defensive midfielder we have, however that doesn't mean he is at the level we need. He does his job of protecting the defence well, and it is always great to have a player like him on the bench for games where you are struggling, but in my opinion you need a defensive midfielder with a bit more in his locker.

For me, a good pair would be Nainggolan and Pjanic both of Roma. They could be our new Mascherano and Alonso as it is those types of players we need to be investing in if we are going to sort out our defence and midfield.

Red Rum

Believable4 Unbelievable5

Nothing to do with BR forcing the 'play it out from the back'. Instant pressure on defense

Agree4 Disagree1

The paiing for Roma is Naiggolan and Keita. Pjanic is an attacking midfielder BUT I see your point.

Agree3 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 05:16:13
Pjanic is one of the best in his position and ATM a move to either Spurs or Liverpool would be a step down.
Roma is in an excellent fight with Juve for the title.
We should try to get Hamsik instead.

Agree3 Disagree3

09 Jan 2015 08:01:29
Sorry but Hendo's best position is right midfield? What are you on mate, he's your classic box to box central midfielder. Further proved by the fact that in his first season he was played out right and we almost sold him, he had 2 seasons in the centre and did so well he's been given the vice captaincy and now he's been moved out right again, people are questioning his performance. As soon as he gets moved into the centre again (e.g. vs Swansea) we look better and he runs games again. Hendo is a CM. Plain and simple

Agree7 Disagree0

Well said hijkle. It's weird how a player with such a severe lack of vision is only behind Fabregas, Sigurdsson and Tadic in terms of assists this season.

Hendo is a class central midfielder, as you say, plain and simple.

I would rather save the money Red Rum and partner Hendo and Can together going forward.

Agree3 Disagree0

09 Jan 2015 09:22:47
Have to disagree about Henderson, think you are under-rating his passing and vision tbf. He may not be Steven Gerrard but has a good range of passing and perfectly capable of hitting cross field balls when necessary but tries more to play the ball shorter/quicker (which i prefer).

As for vision correct me if i'm wrong but doesn't he have the most assist in our whole team? Which considering he doesn't take set pieces is quite impressive

Agree5 Disagree0

I probably didn't make myself clear. I agree that Henderson is a box to box player as I have said in a previous post but I wouldn't have him sat infront of my defence trying to dictate play. I'm not arsed about our central midfielders getting assists, i'm more concerned about how they dictate the flow of the game. For me, Henderson has always played his best football on the right hand side. Not as a winger but as a box to box player. He plays much better when he has the freedom to attack and defend when necessary, not shackled to a central midfield role. The only reason I say behind Lallana is because Lallana is the player in form at the moment. Both players will keep eachother on their toes, there's no doubting that.

Red Rum

Agree0 Disagree2

 
Change Consent