Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
Liverpool Rumours Member Posts
montstar87's Profile
montstar87's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To montstar87's Posts
To montstar87's last 5 rumours posts
To montstar87's last 5 banter posts
To montstar87's last 5 rumour replies
To montstar87's last 5 banter replies
montstar87's rumours posts with other poster's replies to montstar87's rumours posts
15 Jan 2023 19:41:56
Saw something before that chelsea have spent more than us since their new regime took over than we have in something like 10 transfer windows. How are they going to make that work with FFP? Thanks.
1.) 15 Jan 2023 19:52:51
I recall I think possibly Ed002 saying when Newcastle were taken over they were left in good position as were Chelsea with RA wiping all the debt (if that's true) but also, clubs under new takeover are giving leniency with investment to kick start their new club.
2.) 15 Jan 2023 20:04:45
I believe when I new owner comes in they are permitted to spend a certain amount in initial investment. Plus, Chelsea sell many Fri he players every year and also had a transfer ban a few years back. Lastly, I think all they're new signings have been singed up to 7+ year contracts, meaning the fees are spread over the duration of the contract.
3.) 16 Jan 2023 08:19:08
Plus don't forget that you can just write off 1 an a half Bill easily, FFP is great when you have money just not if you have owners who make it the excuse to stick by it and not invest, sooner FSG and that smug little rat Lijnders is gone the better.
4.) 16 Jan 2023 09:31:28
Pep won't be going anywhere.
5.) 16 Jan 2023 13:29:02
What's the issue with Pep? I've always liked the guy!
6.) 16 Jan 2023 14:02:59
Only if you have some fancy new lucrative sponsorship deals Lancaster ;)
I have heard hat UEFA are keeping tabs on Chelsea's recent outlays, so there could be some investigations if they don't follow the rules.
7.) 16 Jan 2023 20:04:15
Hello Lancaster Red, Ljinders writing a follow up Book to "Intensity" this one is called " NO Intensity"!
8.) 16 Jan 2023 23:36:07
There's nowt wrong with Pep. Just people venting at an easy target because they can't contain themselves.
Chelsea have spent a small fortune - where has it got them?
It's not how much you spend, it's how wisely you spend it.
06 Jun 2021 09:29:30
Saw talk of strengthening cm, we seem to have a few injury prone players in there and obviously milner is probably in his last season (hope he stays on in a coaching role! ) . I see all the talk of who we are linked with and can't understand why no one mentions kalvin phillips, everytime I see him he looks brilliant and the perfect player for our midfield. I'm guessing Leeds would also want a hefty fee for him.
1.) 06 Jun 2021 11:25:59
I personally think he's over rated. He is a decent passer and takes a nice set piece. But he's weak on the ball, lacks aggression in general, non-existent in the air, slow to react to danger and often guilty of over playing. He's technically very good and he does work hard but i just think he's lacking in a few too many areas to be good enough for a top 6 team.
2.) 06 Jun 2021 11:39:02
He again would cost £50m plus and he can only play the number 6 role so wouldn’t get in ahead of Fabs. I think if we sign a midfielder he will have to be able to cover at least 2 roles.
3.) 06 Jun 2021 13:54:38
There are better players out there for the money Leeds want.
4.) 06 Jun 2021 14:53:28
Decent midfielder but not the type we need.
5.) 06 Jun 2021 14:57:20
Fabinho is a better player than Kalvin Phillips, who is decent in his own right. I don't see why adding him makes any sense.
6.) 06 Jun 2021 16:58:04
I rate Phillips in fairness but I honestly think he’ll see his career out at Leeds, unless they start to really struggle.
Think we need at least 1 CM in summer, past Thiago, Fab and Hendo we don’t actually have a lot of a quality. Jones is good for his age and will continue to improve. Milner is getting on, still a great figure to have in the dressing room + he’s versatile. Ox and keita cannot stay fit and haven’t shown a great deal to suggest they should be kept. I’d move keita on 100% and possibly ox if a suitable offer came in. (We’d need 2 CM’s if both left) .
Ideally we’ll add Neuhaus/ Bissouma as the definitive CM signing and Aouar/ De Paul/ Sanches (if both ox and keita leave) .
7.) 06 Jun 2021 17:24:37
Fair comments. Just looks tidy when I've seen him. I like the look of rice as well and young enough to be a mainstay for years.
8.) 06 Jun 2021 17:51:10
I haven't seen a lot of bissouma if I'm honest and when I have he hasn't been that stand out I've thought we have to sign him. Why all the hype with him is he really that great?
9.) 06 Jun 2021 23:54:26
RE Bissouma, montstar. It's funny, I asked myself the same thing today when I had a little free time. I haven't seen him much, but the scouting report I read is pretty hyped up. Essentially, he's big, strong, fast, a strong tackler, a great presser, he's good with outlet passes on the counter, and he's a really accurate long passer. He's also a reliable player and can log a ton of good minutes, which already puts him ahead of someone like Keita for me. It sounds like he could really do well with us, considering the way Klopp likes to have our guys play.
11 Mar 2015 09:09:26
Hi eds is there any news on konoplyanka? Thanks
{Ed002's Note - He will be out of contract and moving in the summer. Wolfsburg, Roma, Spurs, Shakhtar and Bayer Leverkusen have shown recent interest in Konoplyanka who is able to sign a pre-contract with any non Ukrainian side. Spurs and Roma have put the most effort in to trying to put a deal in place for the summer.}
1.) 11 Mar 2015 10:18:05
With him turning down roma and saying he wants to play in england do we hold any interest at all?
Cheers
{Ed002's Note - No.}
montstar87's banter posts with other poster's replies to montstar87's banter posts
13 Jun 2021 19:00:11
Stand by my comment the other day on Phillips even though a few disagree. He was immense tonight against a decent Croatia midfield. I think we should be looking at him he would definitely improve us. Used to the high energy having been with bielsa, home grown and wouldn't need adjusting too much. Seems more of a risk to spend big on an untested signing from abroad for me. I appreciate it would probably cost a fair sum to get him and Ed will say we have no interest. Personally just think he'd fit.
{Ed077's Note - doesn't he play a similar position to Fabinho, who was World Class 1 year ago??
1.) 13 Jun 2021 19:12:20
He didn't for England today, he was further forward of rice in abit more of an advanced role.
{Ed077's Note - understood
2.) 13 Jun 2021 19:26:00
Rice played that role today, Phillips was further forward.
100% long pass accuracy
94% pass accuracy
3/ 4 take ons
1 assist.
Not a bad effort.
{Ed077's Note - okay, thanks for the stats.
3.) 13 Jun 2021 20:25:17
Lots of fouls.
4.) 13 Jun 2021 20:34:54
He was very impressive!
5.) 13 Jun 2021 21:37:50
Do we need to buy every player who has a good game?
Leeds wouldn’t want to let him go, he’s far too important to them.
6.) 13 Jun 2021 21:47:29
Buying on the basis of a tournament performance always works well, right?
7.) 13 Jun 2021 21:58:58
Spot on, Mikey. Don’t know where all this love-in with Phillips comes from suddenly. We will not be signing every play that had a good game for England or any other team so not fussed about it. MOTD fever, me thinks.
8.) 13 Jun 2021 22:00:55
Hes a leeds lad so whilst their in the prem and have Bielsa I think he'll stay there.
9.) 14 Jun 2021 02:28:02
Would cost a fortune.
Today's performance added another cool 10 mil. As will each game if he Carrie's on.
Best to leave buying british unless on a free, champsionship/ good deal or the academy.
Far to expensive. Ben white going to go circa 45 mil. We got gomez for 3.4 so keep it like that for the home grown.
{Ed0666's Note - would rather have bissouma or nehaus
10.) 14 Jun 2021 07:31:42
Just because he's a good player doesn't mean he is a right fit for our system. For me, his lack of mobility is a massive concern. He can get away with it at Leeds where he is holding and has a lot of runners in front of him and with England. He would never get away with it at Liverpool.
Someone with better mobility who is a "busier" midfielder is what we need. The qualities we need are good at pressing, good transition player who can protect the ball and carry it up the pitch, obviously good passing and if they can break into the box and make a contribution with goals that would be a bonus.
So for me the ideal player is Neuhaus. The early indications are that is happening and I am very happy with that. If that doesn't come to fruition, I would also be happy with Bissouma, Sabitzer and Gravenberch. There's a few others I would also be happy with.
11.) 14 Jun 2021 08:40:36
Spot on, Rufusthered. Like I said, MOTD fever.
12.) 14 Jun 2021 10:09:04
I don't think it's MOTD fever when the lad has been great all season. MOTD fever is more a few brilliant games recently but not very good all the time whereas Phillips has been very good.
He would be too expensive though, would prefer Bissouma myself.
13.) 14 Jun 2021 12:18:46
Definitely not motd fever. I've seen a lot of Leeds this year and originally posted before his performance y'day. Rufusthered you clearly haven't watched him as you've pretty much described him 🤣 anyway just my humble opinion. I'll back whoever we sign and hope they hit the ground running.
14.) 14 Jun 2021 13:50:46
English premium will likely mean cost I'd too high. Really like him though. maybe if Leeds were to get relegated we could pounce.
Jones should be our focus. He s not all there yet but he s progressing nicely every season. Looking forward to seeing how he looks next season.
15.) 14 Jun 2021 14:17:53
Well montstar I seen him play plenty of times as I enjoy watching Leeds so your humble opinion is wrong there.
He is relatively slow so would not be ideal for making quick breaks or carrying the ball up the field. I've had a look at his stats. His top speed yesterday was 25.4 km/ h. In comparison Mason Mount's top speed was 31.5 km/ h. In fact, the only starter for England slower than him was Declan Rice.
The areas of the pitch he covers has improved since he was in the Championship but is still uncomparable to the likes of Wjnaldum, Henderson and Milner.
{Ed025's Note - speed is not everything in midfield rufus, did you ever see jan molby play mate?..
16.) 14 Jun 2021 14:33:29
Phillips has shown class for sometime definitely not motd fever, would love him at LFC.
17.) 14 Jun 2021 15:28:54
I think it is all a matter of playing style Ed025.
Alonso wasn't quick but it didn't really matter too much the way we played with him as a quarterback carving up the opposition's midfield with cutting through balls.
I also remember Pirlo in his later years didn't really move about the pitch too much. His fellow midfielders were a lot busier than he was in terms of pressing and dribbling whilst he would sit deeper playing glorious long balls like sat nav.
For us, and in particular for the midfielder we should be looking to buy, I think a new addition has to be someone who will be all over the pitch, will help lead the press and quickly carry the ball up the field. Over the last five years, Henderson, Milner and Wijnaldum have been the main guys to carry out that role. Wijnaldum's left, Milner is in the twilight of his career now and over the next couple of seasons there will probably be a passing of the torch with Henderson. There will be a transition to a new starting midfielder in his place as he isn't getting any younger and he is getting more and more injury prone.
Therefore the type of midfielder that we need to prioritise needs to have the physical capabilities to carry out that role.
18.) 14 Jun 2021 15:28:54
I think it is all a matter of playing style Ed025.
Alonso wasn't quick but it didn't really matter too much the way we played with him as a quarterback carving up the opposition's midfield with cutting through balls.
I also remember Pirlo in his later years didn't really move about the pitch too much. His fellow midfielders were a lot busier than he was in terms of pressing and dribbling whilst he would sit deeper playing glorious long balls like sat nav.
For us, and in particular for the midfielder we should be looking to buy, I think a new addition has to be someone who will be all over the pitch, will help lead the press and quickly carry the ball up the field. Over the last five years, Henderson, Milner and Wijnaldum have been the main guys to carry out that role. Wijnaldum's left, Milner is in the twilight of his career now and over the next couple of seasons there will probably be a passing of the torch with Henderson. There will be a transition to a new starting midfielder in his place as he isn't getting any younger and he is getting more and more injury prone.
Therefore the type of midfielder that we need to prioritise needs to have the physical capabilities to carry out that role.
{Ed025's Note - fair enough rufus mate..
19.) 14 Jun 2021 18:09:11
For me, he lacks the mobility to play in our system as a CM. His positional sense is also off maybe due to the way Leeds play which is that they often man mark their opponents instead of playing in zones where the opposing play will be. He also committed too many fouls meaning he is out of position and panics. I would not want him here cos there are a lot better players out there. Good player BUT not LFC material, IMO.
03 Jul 2019 14:13:57
I keep seeing people asking for a Sturridge replacement, yes he was involved in 18 games but he only scored 2 and assisted 1. I would argue that he doesn't bring what we need from a striker either. If origi can carry on like he has with his important goals and Brewster is anywhere near the player we are lead to believe and contributes a few goals here and there while building his experience, I really don't see why we need a sturridge replacement. As much as I loved watching him in his pomp, I really feel we have gotten rid a player who isn't at the level we need anymore (unfairly due to injuries)
1.) 03 Jul 2019 16:45:47
Also he only started four of those eighteen games, playing a total of 500 min this season. That's less than 6 full games.
He scored a cracker against Chelsea, but he was hardly the most effective impact sub and Origi rightfully overtook him. Brewster is a fine replacement.
2.) 03 Jul 2019 19:05:16
Why are we replacing players who DON'T play? Makes no sense to me, personally.
3.) 03 Jul 2019 20:22:12
Sturridge did play, as the OP said, he was involved in 18 games. It's not that hard to understand.
4.) 03 Jul 2019 22:22:15
Saying he was involved in 18 games is a little far fetched, he barely broke into a brisk walk for the vast majority of the time he played, that’s not being involved. His place can be taken by a kid.
5.) 03 Jul 2019 22:52:57
27 appearances. 818 minutes. 4 goals. 2 assists.
Question if his contribution was enough to justify his wage/ place if you want but at least post the truth rather than falsified or twisted stats to suit your argument. One of those goals helped us beat PSG. Had it ended 2-2 we'd have gone out the group and Hendo wouldn't have lifted number 6.
Don't discredit or ignore his contribution to make a cheap point in a transfer debate. It's classless.
6.) 03 Jul 2019 23:14:23
Yeah a few games he came on for the last minute. There was a game where he was standing on the sideline (backwards of course) and the whistle went before he even stepped on the pitch
He had so much promise, its unreal how his career has panned out. And he got 3 not 2. And they were massive goals, 2 of them anyway. The opening goal against psg. You look at how we only just got out of the group. Had psg got a draw we wouldn't have won the 6th. But DS scored early, just like klopp wants and us fans of course.
And that worldie against chelsea was one of the best strikes of the season. We were unbeaten at the time. In fact i think we had won every game, but don't quote me on that. It was a massive goal for us.
Hes off, dunno where, probably china. But take a minute to remember some of the wonder goals he scored, he scored some absolute worldies.
7.) 04 Jul 2019 07:19:27
I wasn't trying to discredit his contribution or take away from the player he was. I said I loved watching him in his pomp, it was a pleasure to see him and Suarez together. I was saying that his time had come to an end with us in my opinion, as he can't offer what we need from a striker, he just can't work hard enough for the team. I don't necessarily think we need a replacement as some people have said. No one will want to come and sit on the bench, let's give youth chance, it's nice seeing a youngster establish himself in the first team.
8.) 04 Jul 2019 10:23:17
No worries montstar. It wasn't aimed directly at your post anyway. More a pre-emptove strike to be honest. The thread just looked to be deviating down the path of 'Sturridge doesn't need replacing because he offered nothing anyway'.
I actually agree with you that Brewster should take his place. It's still a gamble though. Would Brewster have scored key goals against Chelsea and PSG? I hope we'll find out just how good he is this year. We should definitely recognise that Brewster is coming in to fill big boots though. Sturridge may have been on his last legs and no longer justifying his wages, but he still had a touch of class in big moments.
9.) 04 Jul 2019 13:03:33
Good post plain bread summed it up perfectly.
Brewster has big boots to fill and it is a gamble. But, like it wasnt a gamble with Sturridge. West Brom took a gamble on him, lasted less than 90 minutes. West Brom were relegated (tbf they were in big trouble by jan 1st, not saying they got relegated because of of DS. But if anything could have saved them, a fully fit Sturridge firing on all cylinders could've)
No hard feelings monstar, its a site for debate eh, that's what makes it so interesting. I was a massive sturridge fan, had a magic left foot, scoring outrageous goals. I suppose the word "was" says it all.
Brewster is going to be more dynamic at least. Im looking forward to seeing what i can do.
10.) 04 Jul 2019 17:15:21
No hard feelings at all, like you said it's for debates, just wanted to be more clear on my OP.
Roll on the 9th of August!
10 May 2019 12:35:29
Saw a few people were asking about the screening of the final at Anfield. Echo reported that lfc booked the m&s arena 6 months ago due to concerts at Anfield. Keep an eye out for an announcement early next week.
1.) 11 May 2019 02:33:43
I've seen this too, any idea where I can get tickets for the m&s arena and would I need to be a member?
Such a shame because anfield was rocking last year.
21 Apr 2017 11:22:05
Hi everybody I am looking for a ticket to the Southampton game if anyone knows of one it would be much appreciated? Hope everyone has a good weekend. Thanks.
1.) 21 Apr 2017 11:45:42
Only way I no off pal is buy into the Lfc membership of which allows you to apply for match day tickets. First come first serve though as you would expect. I got my 2 v Saints this morning in Anny road.
2.) 21 Apr 2017 12:51:04
Lots of options. few lads I know do tickets. if u are on twitter let me know. I'll dm u. Cheers.
3.) 21 Apr 2017 19:36:45
Hey lfcdiamond1, I am interested in a couple of tickets as well! what is your twitter/ email if it is ok to contact? Any help would be much appreciated!
4.) 21 Apr 2017 19:53:31
Lfc. Im after two for me and my lad.
You can actually sign up for a membership mid season. Only in june and its yearly one and you get buy tickets july and novemeber for first and second half of season respectively.
Then there is just local member sales and local general sale.
Either be a member or have an l1 postcode. Pain tbe ass tbh becuase i live over the water i can't buy ticksts until next season.
So back to lfc. Is your connect all legit and that? How are the prices. Tried ticket master r what ever and there starting at like 145 each.
16 Mar 2017 08:52:37
Eds what's youl opinion on Harry Wilson seems to be on fire for the u23's but not given the same chances as other youngsters? Thanks.
{Ed001's Note - he had to earn his way back in after injuries, he has now got himself on the fringes of the first team squad due to his performances. I don't see the issue, surely that is how it should be?}
1.) 16 Mar 2017 09:44:39
Come on people he's not going to start when he has coutinho and mane in front and if people have not notice we are in a battle to get champions league football not like last session when is was clear the Klopp choice the Europe leauge over the league so the kids can get a chance.
2.) 16 Mar 2017 09:22:51
I think it's more that someone like Woodburn seems to be given more chances than Wilson Ed? I may be mistaken however.
{Ed001's Note - well Woodburn got himself ahead and has deserved his chances, that's just how it is. Wilson has to keep going and he will get there too.}
3.) 16 Mar 2017 11:22:20
Fair enough Ed.
4.) 16 Mar 2017 13:20:47
Have to agree with Ed001 on this, from what i've seen of Wilson this season in U23's he's been fantastic but Woodburn took his chance well and deserves to get more chances. He looked comfortable against Burnley at the weekend and glad to see he got a call up for Wales!
5.) 16 Mar 2017 14:24:13
Absolutely agree with the Ed. It's all about taking your chances and fair play to the lad Woodburn has taken his and hopefully Wilson will get his chance again which is looking very likely.
6.) 16 Mar 2017 14:11:16
Wasn't a criticism of any one just wondered what your thoughts were nice to see our young players getting a chance. Thanks for the reply.
7.) 16 Mar 2017 16:19:18
He should have had his chances when Mane was away. Never understood y he was never given a go when this team needed a winger.
06 Jun 2021 17:51:10
I haven't seen a lot of bissouma if I'm honest and when I have he hasn't been that stand out I've thought we have to sign him. Why all the hype with him is he really that great?
06 Jun 2021 17:24:37
Fair comments. Just looks tidy when I've seen him. I like the look of rice as well and young enough to be a mainstay for years.
11 Mar 2015 10:18:05
With him turning down roma and saying he wants to play in england do we hold any interest at all?
Cheers
{Ed002's Note - No.}
14 Jun 2021 12:18:46
Definitely not motd fever. I've seen a lot of Leeds this year and originally posted before his performance y'day. Rufusthered you clearly haven't watched him as you've pretty much described him 🤣 anyway just my humble opinion. I'll back whoever we sign and hope they hit the ground running.
13 Jun 2021 19:26:00
Rice played that role today, Phillips was further forward.
100% long pass accuracy
94% pass accuracy
3/ 4 take ons
1 assist.
Not a bad effort.
{Ed077's Note - okay, thanks for the stats.
13 Jun 2021 19:12:20
He didn't for England today, he was further forward of rice in abit more of an advanced role.
{Ed077's Note - understood
04 Jul 2019 17:15:21
No hard feelings at all, like you said it's for debates, just wanted to be more clear on my OP.
Roll on the 9th of August!
04 Jul 2019 07:19:27
I wasn't trying to discredit his contribution or take away from the player he was. I said I loved watching him in his pomp, it was a pleasure to see him and Suarez together. I was saying that his time had come to an end with us in my opinion, as he can't offer what we need from a striker, he just can't work hard enough for the team. I don't necessarily think we need a replacement as some people have said. No one will want to come and sit on the bench, let's give youth chance, it's nice seeing a youngster establish himself in the first team.