07 Jan 2015 19:02:02
Would love to hear ed1's opinion on how the club is currently being managed. Ed2 seems to have great insight on the club and she has not got a lot of good things to say of it. Problems with economy and bad transfer policy! And even though we have good young players at the club they are not given a chance Ilori, Alberto and Suso for example. Is BR the right man for the job, I'm starting to have my doubts?

{Ed001's Note - I am not happy with the way the club is being run. It is not just Brendan Rodgers at fault though. The transfer policy, it is a shambles and completely negates the point in spending huge sums developing young players. Then there is the committee itself, it is never a good idea to have a committee making decisions, they always end up being a compromise. Then there is Rodgers and his coaching staff, in particular Achteberg. They are fine at improving the technique of players, but they are not improving positioning or decision making. The teamwork is lacking between players, that is a major worry as some have played together for years but don't have an understanding of each other's game. That has to be laid at the door of the coaching staff. The defensive woes, again the coaching, what are they doing there? Is no one teaching basics of defending???}

1.) 07 Jan 2015
More importnatly is Ed2 a she or a he. I see constant references here to both genders. Just curius not that it really matter or that I dream of getting a concrete honest answer on that.

2.) 07 Jan 2015
Thanks for the quick answer. Do you think that BR is given one last chance let's say if he agrees to work under an DFO or is FSG already looking for a new manager? If they are do you got any names like an short list? If you could choose any won who would it be, realistic that is?

{Ed002's Note - Read the posts - there are hundreds on the subject.}

3.) 07 Jan 2015
07 Jan 2015 20:40:32
Ed001
Spot on. Can we get you onto the board.

4.) 07 Jan 2015
07 Jan 2015 20:42:19
Football at that level is about positioning, marking, runs, and tactics. All players are technically proficent at that point (yes even Andy Carroll) but the difference is the movement and positioning of the players that push them over the top of lower divison players. Sad really if that's the case ed1.

5.) 07 Jan 2015
Which is the job of the coaching staff who by all accounts, are either too incompetent or unwilling to coach up the players on positioning, tracking of runs, timing of headers on set-pieces and defending as a team.

6.) 08 Jan 2015
What is ed001s solution to the problem. Stick with Brendan or appoint somebody else.

{Ed001's Note - a complete revamp of the whole club, including a change of manager.}

7.) 08 Jan 2015
Thanks for the quick answer. Do you think that BR is given one last chance let's say if he agrees to work under an DFO or is FSG already looking for a new manager? If they are do you got any names like an short list? If you could choose any won who would it be, realistic that is?

{Ed001's Note - I don't believe Rodgers would agree to it anyway. They are interested in a few people, AVB and De Boer are of interest. Personally I would say the DoF was the priority, then pick who would work best with the man given that role.}

8.) 08 Jan 2015
07 Jan 2015 19:45:56
Do the owners have a plan ED? Short or Long term? Personally I think it's a complete mess. From being on the brink of Liverpool history last year,, and to go sell the best striker in the world. That for one doesn't make sense seeing as we was so close. Then the players brought in? Not one world class or potentially world class player? And then Changed the entire shape and identity of the team,, I could've understood had we sold Suarez and brought in say Sanchez. Like for Like (even though Luis obviously miles better) Stuck with the same formation ect.
I honestly don't think anyone has any idea what's going on from top to bottom.
I'm not normally interested in finances ect, but I go the games regularly and have done for a long long time, very worried about our club mate

{Ed001's Note - they are having a review of the club done to put a plan in place. We did try to bring in Sanchez, but he was not interested in a move to us.}

9.) 08 Jan 2015
08 Jan 2015 05:32:29
Ed002 has his/ her own reasons for not discussing his/ her gender and we need to respect his/ her wishes. If that's what she wants i'm fine with that