18 Nov 2026 13:17:58
Let's assume there isn't an agenda or conspiracy and we'll just go with sheer incompetence.
Either way, it's already - 10 matches in - had a material influence on the title race. The Forest and Palace penalties against and the penalty we didn't receive against Arsenal (we'll assume the penalty would have been scored) amount to three points lost for us, a minus three impact on goal difference and two additional points for Arsenal. Correct decisions in those three cases alone would have us on 21 points, Arsenal on 24 and us very much in pursuit of the top of the table. More subjectively we might also argue that the red card for Gravenberch against City was unjust and that, without it, that match would have played out as a draw (so that's +1 points and +3 on current goal difference), and that Timber would have been sent off if the correct decision of penalty had been awarded for his pull back on Isak, resulting in Arsenal playing three quarters of that match with 10 men. Reasonable chance in those circumstances that we'd have gone on to win (so that would be +3 points and further improved goal difference and three less points for Arsenal).
There are no outrageous claims in any of that; it is all quite feasible and arguably how things would have played out if laws of the game had been applied correctly. We'd be level with Arsenal on 24 points at the top of the league.
18 Nov 2026 15:37:07
Even if most of us agree with you, at the end of the day and unfortunately, only which team scores the most goals in a game and has the most points at the end of the season, really count and matter. It's left for us fans to ponder over the could haves, should haves and would haves.
18 Nov 2026 16:20:31
Theres a conspiracy allright, but it's not the one you think. Sure, individual refs might be 'in the pocket' of certain clubs, but you have to remember all clubs experience shocking decisions against them at some stage. Go onto any of the cub pages in any forum, and you'll find endless cries of bias and corruption. Arsenal fans are actually the worst for it, they're completely deluded and think all the refs are out to get them.
The truth of it is the big conspiracy is simply that the ref's, pgmol, and former refs all act as a brotherhood, like corrupt cops, and instead of owning up to their errors, they gaslight the fans and try to sweep things under the rug. Of course this affects everybody, and when it happens to your team it feels like everyone's against you, but it's really just incompetency and institutional protection.
It won't be eradicated until 4 things happen: they need to make refereeing a prestigious job, it should come with a (relatively) large pay packet, and they should look to attract ex-pros. Numerous times over the years I've heard ex-pro's say they would be interested in reffing if they weren't paid a pittance. Also, the refs need to be governed by a properly independent body/panel/board (whatever) to avoid this endless gaslighting of the fans over shocking decisions, again ideally made up of well-paid, exceptionally trained experts and ex-pros. There should be no ex-refs involved at the top end, all they do is try and cover for each other. No biased refs, seems obvious but it's not being enforced, for that there needs to be far more effective qualifying, applicants' backgrounds need to be heavily scrutinised and made public for complete transparency. And of course the consistency on rules and the training of them. Far too often we see 2 comparable incidents treated totally differently, or vice versa.
Unfortunately I don't see any of this ever happening.
18 Nov 2026 17:04:43
Shay boils my p*ss, is when come and say that they admit to the mistakes! Like that helps the clubs who it goes against, its points that make a difference
It's like bullseye " see how many points you could have had ".