10 Nov 2026 12:43:07
Just interested to think who you think would cut it in the Premier League given their current standings and skill set.
It's not hard to see were miles ahead of other leagues, players who have come here with big reputations who didn't hit the heights have said how different this league is, it's the lower league teams that surprise them.
So I wonder who people think would cut it over here and i'm talking about the ones who carry a big rep and those who you think would work like a joao neves or kvratshelia and those who have a big rep but can't see it working in this league and would surely be humbled.
10 Nov 2026 13:00:05
Nico Paz seems to have the physicality to succeed, looks a serious player. Yamal and Mbappe are obvious ones because they're so elite and Olise and Raphinia have already proved they can mix it. I don't think Kvara would suit the prem, Dembele is too fragile as is Vitinha. Joao Neves, Nuno Mendes and Hakimi would all thrive. Vini Jr would flop, Bellingham would be even better than he is now. Pedri could go either way, he might get thrown around like a rag doll or might be able to manipulate the gung-ho approach and dictate games
I have zero qualification for the above and it's just a hunch but I'm sticking my 2 pence in anyway.
10 Nov 2026 14:16:33
All depends on if we are talking about the Premier League or this extreme version Arteta and the referees have co-created which, in Jorge Valdano's famous words, can only be described as "s*** hanging from a stick"?
10 Nov 2026 14:39:13
I have no idea as I only watch Liverpool games.
I think we need to get back to basics in regard to recruitment and transfer policy. Under Klopp it was about identity, what attributes does the player have to complement the squad and do they have the mindset and attitude.
I think if we get this right then success will follow. Now that Edwards and Hughes have gone I hope the days of them playing real life football manager are over and we can get back to building a squad rather than buying shiny toys without any strategy.
That said, whilst unbalanced, there is the bones of a very good team.
{Ed025's Note - i was a massive fan of Klopp MOT and not just because of football management skills, he looked at players who had good values and a stable family life and he looked favourably on religion, it was not just about the skill level mate it was about the whole package and that for me was why he got the absolute best out of the team...a great strategy for me..
10 Nov 2026 14:40:24
PL is curently the best league for parking the bus and spending the most money.
Its a far fetch from when it was the standout most entertaining league in world football.
10 Nov 2026 14:59:26
RPMcMurfo in reply to your actual question mate would love to see all the worlds biggest hitters in the PL league having a go Mbappe, Yamal, Valverde, Kvaratskhelia, Hakimi etc.
10 Nov 2026 15:39:16
Your right Jk - but football in general in most prominent leagues are going through the same phase of drab football based on the modern player being great physical athletes but lacking in any great flair as mentioned by FPF
The players you mentioned are the exception.
I see it a lot in local league football down here. Young lads that are as fit as fiddles with the obligatory big biceps but zero flair.
10 Nov 2026 15:40:12
If Michael Edwards gets stick for what he did in his second stint at the club, he deserves enormous credit for bringing in Salah, Mane, VVD, Alisson, Robertson, Fabinho, in his first spell. That always gets conveniently overlooked, as he remains a whipping boy, along with Hughes, Lijnders, Slot et al.
Klopp obviously played a huge part in our success and is an absolute legend, but Edwards has to receive credit, if we're going to slaughter him for what happened later.
{Ed666's Note - agreed mate
10 Nov 2026 22:23:14
Fair point Rome but I just don't like his claiming credit for everything in the media and he done great analysing data and at looking at qualities as set out by Klopp. So yes he was brilliant and then on his second stint he let his ego and wet dreams affect his better judgement.
10 Nov 2026 23:05:13
The Premier League is the most competitive league in Europe and probably the world but we don't have any elite teams in the league right now.
Since the days of Pep's City going up against Klopp's Liverpool the top teams have got worse and the rest have got better. It doesn't help that Arteta has created a style of football that makes me want to watch lawn bowls instead. Ably assisted by the most incompetent (some would say corrupt) officiating the world has ever seen.
You'd have to say that PSG, Barca and Bayern Munich are far and away much better than anything we can offer.
For that reason you'd have to say that any player from any of those teams would be a good addition.
{Ed666's Note - I’m a big fan of lawn bowls mate. It’s super fascinating when you get into it.
11 Nov 2026 06:50:25
@Ris
You do realize you only play Arsenal twice a season right? Arteta's style has no relevance to how Liverpool or other 19 clubs wishes to play. He is not responsible for where Liverpool are placed in the table.
11 Nov 2026 08:09:38
Ed 666 there's a bowling green in the park near me who were recruiting, was tempted but I'm only 54.
{Ed666's Note - Are you trying to tell me with a straight face you’re not old mate?? ?…