25 Mar 2026 18:18:27
Ed025
Kelleher is better than Pickford all day long.
Did you rate Pickford against Arsenal last week did you?
{Ed025's Note - lay off the drugs Hughesy, Pickers is miles better than Kelleher mate, all goalies will make the odd mistake that goes with the territory..
25 Mar 2026 19:25:28
Ed025 the blue tint on your glasses is very strong at times.
I mean you still think Lucas Digne was a better left back than Robbo.
Pickford is far too erratic he is like Ramsdale always making the simplest of saves look like Gordon Banks save against Pele.
{Ed025's Note - come on Grino...credit where its due mate..
25 Mar 2026 20:34:59
I will accept Pickford is better than Kelleher, but Pickford isn't that great either.
{Ed025's Note - hes not perfect Tom...but he is very good mate..
25 Mar 2026 20:44:56
Hessel, I find it hard to judge, to be fair, because this season is Kelleher's first season as a number 1, but from what I've seen, I think he has had a good season. I don't remember any bad matches for him.
25 Mar 2026 20:34:01
Ed025 am just not a fan of Pickford I find him far to rash. I feel while you have been struggling for a most of his time at Everton that sort of makes him look better than he is because he has been busy most of the time.
The very best keepers don't have a lot to do and then they pull of the saves out of the blue but as I said earlier Ed he is to erratic to be that I feel the best keepers can make the defence in front of them feel calm.
{Ed025's Note - he is a match winner Grino, yes he will have the odd wobble but the top 20 saves of the season all include him mate..
25 Mar 2026 21:20:48
Both are not bad, but only one has Red Blood.
{Ed025's Note - and one is world class Peter.. :)
25 Mar 2026 21:35:18
T-Rex better than Kelleher? That's a bold statement right there.
{Ed025's Note - yet a totally true one..
25 Mar 2026 21:25:32
I think Pickford is a terrible keeper. Just my opinion. No dig at you ED25. I'd have Karius before him and that's saying something.
{Ed025's Note - hes Englands No1 for a reason SG...hes the best in the land mate..
25 Mar 2026 22:11:17
Pickford is a good keeper. Would he get into a title challenging team? Probably not. However, the Karius shout must be a wind up.
Kelleher, on the other hand, is a much closer call, and, now that he is playing regularly, will probably go on to have a similar career to Little Arms. I mean, he already has more trophies ;).
{Ed025's Note - but would he get in a side challenging for a CL spot...breaking news...hes already in one.. :)
25 Mar 2026 22:41:13
If only he had average sized arms.
25 Mar 2026 22:51:47
Both JP and CK are suspect under crosses.
25 Mar 2026 23:18:27
To be fair, Pickford is probably in the Top 15 goalkeepers to have played the 2025-26 season ever.
26 Mar 2026 09:54:02
Very much WY. but JP is still horrendous ED25. Just because Tuchel has him in goal doesn't make him good.
{Ed025's Note - its not just Tuchel SG, every England manager wanted him in, and thats because hes world class my friend..
26 Mar 2026 10:14:16
Ain't no shifting you ED25! And I mean your opinion, not as in a good Fri night!
{Ed025's Note - im very set in my ways SG, and being right all the time does not help me one little bit mate.. :)
26 Mar 2026 23:50:53
World class is a stretch.
{Ed001's Note - depends on what kind of deluded world you live in, if you think Prickford is class of any kind! He makes a simple save and we get told it is the best save of all time, when it was the kind of save a Premier League level keeper should make in their sleep. He made one the other day, he was already moving the same way and the ball was hit right at where he was going, but the commentators were having orgasms about it being a great save. It was not even a good save. But he turns round and celebrates it like he had to reverse direction and fling himself full length to get to it. It is embarrassing to watch such dross being worshipped and held up like a top class keeper. Neville Southall must get so annoyed watching this hero worship of someone not fit to lace his boots.}