08 Nov 2026 19:39:44
I really don't understand all this negativity around Isak. Lets be honest Haaland stands about about not doing much and yet we would love him to be at Liverpool. Salah did nothing unless he had the ball at his feet and even then he was past his best last season.
He didn't press or defend. As long as Isak is scoring goals that's what he was bought for.
08 Nov 2026 19:43:15
Stop all this logical wizardry talk Alwaysred ?.
08 Nov 2026 20:07:07
Thought he was Orite today me. Looked sharper than usual. Should've scored that 1on1 tho.
08 Nov 2026 20:08:01
7 in 9. Second only to Haaland. Going at just under a goal a game; will be 30 in all competitions at this rate. Isak is doing exactly what it says on the tin. Notable that Haaland and Isak don't have a single assist between them but, like I said, what it says on the tin.
I was thinking about this; it seems feasible he might score 20+ in the league and get close to 30 in all competitions and yet still not receive full approval from fans.
{Ed666's Note - he’s score more if he remembered what movement was
08 Nov 2026 20:43:53
Today was an odd game for Isak, at times he seemed more mobile than usual however for much of the game his movement was poor. It's hard to criticise when his goal return has been so good but I'm watching him play and I don't see the movement enough.
Where are the runs off the shoulder of the defender, he certainly doesn't bully the defenders and his hold up play is pretty poor. Again, hard to criticise when the goals are flowing but I want more.
08 Nov 2026 21:15:37
bit of chicken and egg, but if Isak can do nothing but score 30 league goals a season for multiple years then I guess he would have justified it lol
my sense is that he isn't the type of striker that we need for this system. But hey, happy with the goals lol.
08 Nov 2026 21:33:11
I saw Isak running back and defending against Palace. He put in a decent cardio shift for once. It was his forward runs that were missing.
{Ed666's Note - that’s like saying I went to see Oasis in concert and they were on stage but forgot to sing!
08 Nov 2026 21:53:15
Isak looks like that because the pressing structure is not there yet. Our average defensive line is still way too deep. The whole formation needs to push up more. The distances are massive at the moment.
{Ed666's Note - I’m not quite sure how the press is not mastered by now? They’ve had plenty of time to learn when to trigger and hunt..it leads me to believe the players are at fault because they can’t fathom the tactics.
08 Nov 2026 22:09:29
Because people recognise that if he was more active we would create more opportunities, which is pretty key because we're majorly lacking in creativity across the front line, we just don't look dangerous the majority of the time. Personally this is exactly what I expected from Isak and I don't see it changing too much right now. He's very much a fox in the box and always has been.
I think people need to realise this is also by design, Isaks is very much under instruction. We've got just 1 fit and capable striker at the moment and a ton of matches still to play. Let's not forget that he's really not that long back from breaking his leg (in the grand scheme of things), this is essentially his first properly competitive run of form since the 24/25 season, and our only other striker won't be properly match fit for a few more months.
We simply cannot afford Isak picking up unnecessary injuries, the club will protect its investment, and Iraola will protect his star player. I'm surprised he's not running around out there head to toe in bubble wrap.
Not to mention with hm being injury prone his output has always been tailored, even at Newcastle, there was always lots of walking between plays.
I agree, very similar in practice to Haaland but he can get away with it because of how physical he is.
09 Nov 2026 06:58:24
Isak is a very good goalscorer but isn't suited to the way the team should play. He probably cant' get stuck in and press aggresively and make the dangerous runs at pace the team wants and needs because of his susceptibility to injury and stop start acceleration is probably the main cause of his injuries.
Hopefully his run of scoring continues and maybe a big team come in for him in the summer, although as European football stands right now there aren't many with the funds to sign him at a price near to which we paid.
09 Nov 2026 07:40:11
Our press hasn't improved, which suggests the players just can't do it effectively, not that it's not being coached. Palace played through it easily yesterday which sort of renders it pointless. I'm not sure you can play a true press with Isak in the team, but I'd rather him in the team so I'd prefer we adapt the tactics.
09 Nov 2026 10:09:00
Spot on, Clearview. Our press is very disjointed at m so might as well ask Isak to just stay up there so we can find him.