Liverpool Banter 262633

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.


14 Nov 2026 11:31:45
I watched Florian Wirtz play for Germany yesterday. For the life of me I don't understand why he is not able to reproduce the same form with LFC. Firmino level mastery. I know a lot of variables are involved, but still.



14 Nov 2026 11:57:58
Been decent since last International break to be fair Aray

Working with Jurgan will do him wonders.



14 Nov 2026 12:07:49
AyAy - The issue isn't Wirtz. It is as clear as day that he is a step ahead of his teammates in terms of sheer talent and vision. If Wirtz gets 15 goals and 10 assists this season, then will people be happy? Give him a midfield base and some runners to aim for, and you have the best playmaker in Europe, period.



14 Nov 2026 12:11:09
Wirtz just needs runners ahead of him.

I'm guessing for Germany that runner is Havertz.

I'd love to see Wirtz hit the heights for Liverpool. I do believe some of the criticism he comes in for is unwarranted.



14 Nov 2026 12:30:09
The talent is unquestioned. But clearly that's not the entire picture or what's all that is needed (the variables I mentionned).



14 Nov 2026 12:33:10
Lowe would you say that his Leverkusen team were a step ahead of this Liverpool team in regards to talent and vision?

If that's the case then Liverpool should buy those Leverkusen players.

Except Frimpong who is a step behind this Liverpool team in talent and vision.



14 Nov 2026 12:50:39
JK - No, I would obviously not say that. I don't know why you would come to a conclusion like that. This Liverpool team is better in every position. That Leverkusen team, however, was well coached and more than the sum of its parts. This Liverpool team is currently the opposite, though Iraola is changing that, make no mistake.


Wirtz is our best player, but we have a quite a few players in our team that think they are. We'd be much better if those players played to be picked out by Wirtz.



14 Nov 2026 14:12:21
I didn't come to that conclusion mate. I asked it as a question.

Just seen it said a lot that Wirtz struggles because his team mates aren't on his level but he was lauded at Leverkusen.

Wirtz is a top class player no doubts but not sure if he is Liverpools best player. He's definitely not presented enough evidence as of yet on the pitch in a Liverpool shirt.



14 Nov 2026 16:15:16
Let's see wirtz with better midfielders behind him.



{Ed025's Note - you make it sound as though the other midfielders are the problem Ron and not Wirtz?. he has been as guilty as anyone for losing the ball, pulling out of challenges and misplacing passes mate..

14 Nov 2026 17:26:28
All I keep hearing is he needs better runners in front of him, better midfielders behind him. How about Wirtz himself steps up and proves his worth! Top players perform regardless of whose alongside them.



{Ed025's Note - spot on Rome, the Wirtz apologists cant see no wrong in him mate..

14 Nov 2026 17:48:53
I like Wirtz and feel that he is one of the scapegoats this year because of the price. His performances are hindered because I feel he puts a lot of pressure on himself while playing for us, which I don't know he can overcome. The other thing is the physicality, I feel he has found some difficulties on that.

The other issue is the team around him. For some reason that frustrates me, our forwards do not like to move into space while Wirtz is looking for a first pass and sometimes he does without like at it. Meaning, the wingers are not in the same wavelenght as Wirtz and I don't know if that will improve.



14 Nov 2026 18:10:13
Dominican, have you thought perhaps Wirtz should get on the same wavelength as our wingers? It's excuse after excuse for him.



14 Nov 2026 18:10:14
Imagine how good Stevie G would have been with better midfielders and runners ahead of him.

Still managed to be world class without them mind ??‍♂️.



14 Nov 2026 20:12:08
The general message/agenda is that everyone else is at fault for Wirtz not playing as well as he should. Personally I think he is being found out by the speed and maybe even the physicality of the PL compared to when plays for Germany, Leverkusen or even the CL.



{Ed025's Note - im with you Irish..

14 Nov 2026 21:50:44
Wirtz is well capable, that much we know, but he strikes me as mentally weak, that won't work in the Prem. Were Klopp still here, it might have been a different story, his man management is exceptional, I think Florian could have hit the ground running. In fairness to him, he's been better this season, he does cover a lot of ground, the kid is clearly trying, his ability to find pockets of space is arguably the best in the league but he's just not doing enough with it, he's still lacking that creative spark.

Sure, you can point fingers at Isak and Barcola, etc., for not providing runs, but Wirtz in the Bundesliga was making his own runs, breaking lines, taking on his man, popping off shots and we're just not really seeing any of that. He strikes me as a bit of a quiet lad, a homebird, somebody who lacks confidence in unfamiliar surroundings. The kids still pretty young, I think had he spent a couple of years in Spain or Italy before he came to us we might have seen a more mature player with an improved ability to adjust, but here we are.

I hope it works out. I think the kid deserves the season to prove himself, but the bench is calling his name in my opinion. This dedicated 10 with the double pivot business is not helping things in the middle of the park, I'd like to see us try and solidify the midfield, and I think a mid 3 of Trey, Macca and Dom are our best options for that right now. And who knows, a short stint on the bench might just give him the kick he needs to reignite that creative spark for this run into the new year. Hopefully he comes back from the international break full of confidence.



14 Nov 2026 21:55:54
Right now, we are a team of individuals. We have enough individual talent to win some games.
When, and I think it will be soon, we start playing as a team, we will be a lot better and Wirtz will start to shine. Lots of moving parts to this season and I fully expect us to finish stronger than we started.



15 Nov 2026 06:26:54
Bit nuts calling Wirtz our best player, the fact of the matter is that he needs a team built around him and he is only ever as good as the players around him because he is a connective player who links everything up in the final third rather than somebody who is going to nutmeg three players or hit one into the top corner. Not saying that he can't do those things on occasion, but it's not his game generally to take over a game on his own.

I think both perspectives in this thread are correct but I have always said this, Wirtz has been guilty of playing within himself and he does look rattled when things aren't coming off for him or he's going through a run of bad form. At the same time he does always show for the ball and he doesn't go hiding on or off the ball, even if he does look very much a confidence player when it comes to the quality of his performances.

I'm not sure that Trey, Macca and Dom gives us more solidity in the middle of the park. Dom as a 10 just doesn't work right now, not without Salah and Trent for him to work with. Dom in theory offers incredible pressing from the 10 position, but he doesn't convince me that he is doing better than Wirtz in that regard, both of them run around a lot but not at the exact times and with enough coordination with their team mates to really make a discernible difference. Wirtz meanwhile has one elite quality, which is dropping into pockets of space and then linking the play, making lightning fast decisions on what to do with the ball, whether to keep it a split second longer or whether to let go of it immediately.

Dom is just slow in the center of the pitch to make a choice of anything other than either running with the ball himself or hesitating before playing it sideways or back, and doesn't have the vision in the final third, his best attribute in the final third is receiving a pass to shoot from outside the box or arriving late in the box himself, not at all in trying to orchestrate play himself unless it's to try and create space to shoot. Wirtz is always looking to make something happen for others and to try and create imbalance in the opposition defense, Dom as a 10 in our title winning season's job was just laying the ball of for Salah to create or giving it to Trent out wide if he wasn't in a shooting position himself, he was never a creator himself. Do you think Dom could work with Barcola, Isak or Ekitike the way Wirtz has? Absolutely not.

I would say Wirtz has not played well on the balance of things this season, sure, but at the same time he is an extremely important part of our team under Iraola, you can see how central he is to us advancing into the final third and then trying to feed Barcola or Isak. If his final ball can be more consistent, which I think we have seen he can be when he's not playing for us, and if he can be more switched on with his pressing, he will flourish. At least we know the attitude and willingness is there, and that's the most important part.



15 Nov 2026 09:00:28
I'm with the Rover too, the Premier League is the hardest league to adapt to.



16 Nov 2026 05:50:16
PB, I'm not talking about Dom in the 10, I'm talking about dropping the dedicated 10, playing a proper 3 man midfield, where Trey is a more traditional holding 6 and Dom/Macca play as 8's, allowing Isak to float between a 9 and false 9 in order to get him more involved and simultaneously create the space in behind to utilise Barcolas' pace.

Grav has been dirt, Macca and Trey have been much better, Wirtz offers nothing defensively, and the dedicated 10 leaves us exposed without a proper DM or wingers who can pitch in, as we're effectively playing 4 up front. Endo's not up to scratch, nor is McConnell, so, for argument's sake, let's assume we should be looking to solidify the midfield with what we've got, get Isak more involved and figure out how to utilise Barcolas pace, transfer windows aside, what would you suggest if not Trey, Macca and Dom?



16 Nov 2026 08:43:16
Wirtz is the standout footballer in the club at the moment. He has great football intelligence and is starting to show what he is capable of doing. He hasn't shone because, last season, there was no actual sustained period of the team playing well and that was primarily down to Slot and his staff. This season the group of players is slowly moving towards being an actual team that has an understanding of what they are to do as individual players and collectively as a team. Wirtz was attempting things that his team mates weren't geared up to anticipate. That's not solely the fault of his team mates, Wirtz could have / should have tailored his game (he has the relent to do it) but there was no guidance from the coaching staff.

AI has turned the ship around and the team seem to be more attuned as to their roles and what they can expect from others. Once Eki is back, I think he, and Isak, who, as discussed recently, is playing under orders to play within himself until Eli is back as we don't have much in the way of goal scoring back-up, will build up their movement and will be fed opportunities by Wirtz who will be able to use his football intelligence to 'put them in'.



 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent