Liverpool Banter 262182

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.


25 Sep 2026 15:13:48
13 of the last 22 Premier League titles have been won by clubs that are now known to have seriously breached financial rules, almost indisputably resulting in significant sporting advantage. What a stain on the sport and the history of the English top flight title.



25 Sep 2026 16:18:32
Both our recent titles are even bigger achievements than they appeared at the time.



25 Sep 2026 16:22:36
I wouldn't go that far. If we were talking about doping or match-fixing, I would agree with you.

But from a purely sporting perspective, their achievements still stand. There is nothing you can take away from them as a group of athletes. They have played some sensational football and that part is fair and square.

You have to separate the finances from the athletic achievement. Their team was still the best with no cheating on the field of play.



25 Sep 2026 16:44:29
Spot on, Babbity, absolutely bang on.



25 Sep 2026 16:46:48
Babbity: Huh?

Why did they break the rules and go to such efforts to get around the regulations, then try to cover it up and deny it? Surely it was so that they could spend more money on players; transfer fees, contracts, agents, etc. And why would they want to do that? So that they could build an unstoppable team with £50m players in every position (when £50m was still a lot of money) + more on the bench. And then yes they may well have played some sensational football but that's because their financial cheating allowed them to construct a team that didn't have a single weakness.

When the finances are being used directly to build the team and to ensure that nobody can compete with them, you can't simply separate the finances from the on-field achievement. That team and that group of players should not have been possible for Manchester City to put together if they had stayed within the rules.

That's the whole point of this all along isn't it?



25 Sep 2026 17:07:28
With RR on this. They had no weaknesses for a number of years, which makes it all the more incredible that we ran them so close for 2-3 seasons. Kaiser Klopp.



25 Sep 2026 17:42:09
Justice Klopp and the reds. We were screwed out of 2 more PL titles.



25 Sep 2026 18:21:39
If they'd played by the rules, it is almost certain that the group of athletes could not have been brought together, No doubting they were a great squad of players but they cheated to being the squad together. The first thing they should do is strip the club of their titles, irrespective of awarding them to the runners-up or not.



25 Sep 2026 18:58:44
Babbitty - the winning of those titles were achieved by an accumulation of very good & great players through unfair financial means.



25 Sep 2026 19:14:40
RR, honestly I don't like phrases like "that team and group of players shouldn't have been possible." Why shouldn't it have been possible? For me, it goes too close to the MLSification of football where we try to deliberately restrict teams' squad-building in order to create more competition.

The issue with making too much out of the finances is that there are a lot of inequities on the financial side of football. Like was it fair that Abramovich did for Chelsea what Abu Dhabi did for City but he benefitted from doing it years before the rule changes?

That's why it's better to separate the sport from the finances. Did City as a group of athletes cheat? No. Therefore their sporting success is fair and genuine and still stands.

If City as an organisation cheated, then punish them from this point on. I would suggest a significant transfer ban is best. But I think retrospectively stripping them of titles would be hollow and not actually leave people satisfied.



25 Sep 2026 19:16:31
Without wanting to speak for Babbity, I assume he means the players assembled still had to win the competitions, and they did so playing to the same "rules on the pitch" as everyone else.

Nobody denies the team wouldn't have been as dominant if the club hadn't cheated, but the players themselves weren't cheating.

Hate the club for it, and there's an asterisk on everything they have achieved, but players still put the effort in.



25 Sep 2026 19:34:30
Babbity, the "athletes" are collateral damage here and as tough as it is for them, it is what it is and they should be peeved at City for hiding these things from them and lied to them.

When OM got relegated for match-fixing in the "VA-OM" scandal of 1993, no one gave a crap about the "players" who won the title (and the CL that year, btw) in that 92/93 season. It is such a despicable scandal that no one in France talks about it, let alone OM supporters.

At the end of the day, City is the guilty party here and anyone associated with that club is going to get it, whether they like it or not. Maybe City should have done things above board. You know, like many other clubs did, perhaps?



25 Sep 2026 20:10:37
I'm not sure you can feel sorry for any of the players.
They knew exactly what they were signing up for when they joined them and have done remarkably well financially from it.



26 Sep 2026 01:07:56
Almost undisputably.
What does that mean?



26 Sep 2026 02:53:08
Sorry @Babbity, the squad that was assembled would not have been assembled without falsifying contracts, etc, the athletes were brought together by misuse of finances.

Having been assembled, the athletes received massive financial benefits through the improper use of finances - or are you suggesting that they played for the love of the game? I have little doubt that the players were not complicit but they were still paid.

They were an excellent team and they had two of the best midfielders I have ever seen in Rodri and KDB and the lad Ken Aguerro was no bad player.

I think the argument that 'they still had to win the games' is specious. The group that played so well was brought together by finance and the finances were outside the laws of the game.

You can't seperate finances and athletic performance. The finances were the platform for the performance and without the funds to bring in the players they wouldn't have had the same team / squad.



26 Sep 2026 02:54:11
Sir, sir, pick me sir. Does ir mean they are disputable, sir?



26 Sep 2026 11:07:02
It's like taking a team of 15 year olds, lying on their registrations to enter them into an U12 competition

They'd win it fair and square on the pitch, so the sporting competition remained. But, just the little inconvenience that they broke the rules to put an invalid team on the pitch.



 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent