Liverpool Banter 262654

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.


18 Nov 2026 10:58:00
Even more egregious than the panel's ruling of the Isak shirt pull incident vs Arsenal.

The panel's comments regards Kerkez penalty incident vs Palace:

"After reviewing the latest round of Premier League games, the panel "unanimously" agreed that Harrington's penalty decision was "incorrect, " as contact was "inevitable."

They, however, also unanimously agreed on the non-intervention of VAR from Michael Salisbury, "on the basis that it was not a clear and obvious error."

FFS the refs decisions was deemed to be a clear error but not clear and obvious enough for VAR to get involved.

What are we doing here.



18 Nov 2026 11:08:52
Same thing they've been doing for years mate. Manipulating the results with Bias decisions for financial gain.



18 Nov 2026 12:29:29
No idea how they come to these conclusions, seems like it's just another opportunity for them to try and gaslight the fans, manipulate opinions and attempt to sweep these mistakes under the rug.



18 Nov 2026 12:52:11
They unanimously agreed that it was an non clear and obvious but definite error.



18 Nov 2026 13:33:11
Let's be honest, VAR is used for no other reason than try and provide justification for the referee's decision, rather than actually get to the correct decision. If they actually scrap the 'clear and obvious' narrative and actually state it will be utilised to get the right decision, it may be half useful.

Cheers.



18 Nov 2026 14:23:45
Faithworks and Chewy, that is the exact same thing they did with the Forest pen that wasn't.

They said the pen should not have been given as the incident wasn't worthy of one.

Then with the other side of their mouth, they said that VAR not intervening to ask the ref to check the monitor (which would have avoided all of this, btw) was the right decision.

Oh and who was VAR that day? The Notorious BIG a. k. a The Notorious Michael Oliver.

I mean like I've been saying, these guys are just playing in our faces and they can because they know nothing will happen.



18 Nov 2026 16:13:05
This is the absolute problem with VAR, the term clear and obvious is a catch all ambiguous statement used to absolve refs of incorrect decisions.

There is no logical reason how a panel can adjudge that the kerkez penalty was a unanimous incorrect call however it didn't meet the threshold for clear and obvious error'. The two statements can't co exist in a logical world unless you want to create confusion intentionally. The PGMOL and Premier League are massive industries and professions so I can't be persuaded that someone in a high position hasn't accepted that this clear and obvious rule is problematic and therefore it is there by intention.



18 Nov 2026 17:39:27

Anybody reckon in years to come,there'll be repercussions in the shape of a betting scandal involving senior officials and leading referees,it stinks that bad at the minute of somebody benefiting from some absolute s****house decisions.



18 Nov 2026 16:21:19
I think (if this is still how VAR works) the problem is that VAR won't intervene if what the ref says to them as the game is happening is what happens, even if he makes the wrong interpretation. Maybe the Ed's know if that's right, I'm sure that's how it was originally operating anyway. So, let's say the ref says there's a clash of heads and gives a pen- whether that interpretation is total bollocks or not, if there has been a clash of heads he doesn't get sent to the monitor.


If that's still how it works it's clearly a big problem, but I think that is the premise of the clear and obvious error- if what the ref says he saw actually happened then they don't get involved.



 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent