16 Aug 2017 11:58:34
Ed would you say Matip is looking slack because of the fact he has Lovren alongside him and Henderson playing poorly infront? I expect Hendo to get better as he gains fitness but Lovren definitely needs repacing.
{Ed001's Note - no, I just don't think he is good enough.}
16 Aug 2017 12:27:48
Matip appears to want be the next Alan Hansen - reading the game and making interceptions rather than getting physical with center forward. This would be OK if he was to boss the other defenders around and the midfield to make sure he has cover in the right areas to allow him to be the last man.
But he doesn't - Lovren is more physical and really they should work well together - but neither of them lead the defence - nor does Migs.
All three seem to try and concentrate on their own games - what we need is someone who brings the defence together. that's what made John Terry and Carra play above their natural ability - their organisational skills, leadership and bravery.
I am not sure VVD has those attributes.
I would sooner we looked at CB who defended first and was vocal and brave - give me a younger version of Scott Dann or Wes Morgan for example.